diff options
Diffstat (limited to 'doc/rfc/rfc2604.txt')
| -rw-r--r-- | doc/rfc/rfc2604.txt | 1627 |
1 files changed, 1627 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/doc/rfc/rfc2604.txt b/doc/rfc/rfc2604.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6aa09a3 --- /dev/null +++ b/doc/rfc/rfc2604.txt @@ -0,0 +1,1627 @@ + + + + + + +Network Working Group R. Gellens +Request for Comments: 2604 Qualcomm +Category: Informational June 1999 + + + Wireless Device Configuration (OTASP/OTAPA) via ACAP + +Status of this Memo + + This memo provides information for the Internet community. It does + not specify an Internet standard of any kind. Distribution of this + memo is unlimited. + +Copyright Notice + + Copyright (C) The Internet Society (1999). All Rights Reserved. + +Abstract + + Wireless carriers today are faced with creating more efficient + distribution channels, increasing customer satisfaction, while also + improving margin and profitability. Industry trends are pushing the + sale of handsets further into the retail channel. The cost and + effort of provisioning handsets, activating users, and updating + handset parameters can be greatly reduced by using over-the-air + activation mechanisms. A comprehensive and extensible means for + over-the-air provisioning and handset parameter updating is required. + + One approach is to purchase EIA/TIA/IS-683A (Over-the-air Service + Provisioning of Mobile Stations in Spread Spectrum Systems) + equipment. The cost of this has led carriers to seek alternative + solutions. A very viable means for providing over-the-air (OTA) + provisioning is to leverage the rollout of IS-707 data services + equipment, which most carriers are in the process of deploying. This + paper presents an approach to OTA provisioning that utilizes the + deployment of IS-707 to deliver OTA provisioning and parameter + upgrading. + + IS-707 data services makes available several methods of providing + over-the-air provisioning and parameter updating. A well thought-out + approach utilizing Internet-based open standard mechanisms can + provide an extensible platform for further carrier service offerings, + enhanced interoperability among back-end services, and vendor + independence. + + This paper describes a viable and attractive means to provide + OTASP/OTAPA via IS-707, using the ACAP [ACAP] protocol. + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 1] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + +Table of Contents + + 1. Terms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 + 2. Feature Descriptions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 + 2.1. OTASP Feature Description . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 + 2.2. OTAPA Feature Description . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 + 3. Operation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 + 3.1. Initial Provisioning Activity . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 + 3.2. OTASP for Authorized Users . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 + 3.3. OTAPA Activity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 + 4. Requirements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 + 4.1. General Requirements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 + 4.2. OTASP Requirements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 + 4.3. OTAPA Requirements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 + 4.4. Provisioning Server Requirements . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 + 4.5. Security Requirements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 + 5. Architecture . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 + 5.1. ACAP over TCP/IP . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 + 5.1.1. Mobile Authentication and A-Key Generation . . . . . 12 + 5.1.2. Mobile Identification . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 + 5.1.3. ACAP Server . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 + 5.1.4. Overview of ACAP Structure . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 + 5.1.5. Data Organization and Capabilities . . . . . . . . . 13 + 5.1.5.1. Structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 + 5.1.5.2. Conventions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 + 5.1.6. Dataset . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 + 5.1.6.1. Entries and Attributes . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 + 5.1.6.2. NAM Records . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 + 5.1.6.3. Server Roaming Lists . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 + 5.1.6.4. Requested-Data Record . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18 + 5.1.6.5. Sample Server Entry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18 + 5.1.7. Administrative Client . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 + 5.1.8. Mobile Client . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 + 5.2. WAP with ACAP . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22 + 5.3. Network-Resident vs. Configuration Data . . . . . . . . 23 + 5.4. Intellectual Property Issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 + 6. Handset Protocol Suites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 + 6.1. ACAP over TCP/IP . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 + 7. IS-683A Compatibility . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 + 7.1. OTASP Operations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 + 7.2. OTASP Call Flow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 + 7.3. OTAPA Operations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 + 7.4. OTAPA Call Flow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 + 8. Alternative Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 + 8.1. IS-683A over TCP/IP . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 + 8.1.1. OTAF Server . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 + 8.1.2. Interface Application . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 + 8.1.3. Protocol Handset Suite . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 2] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + 8.2. Browser-Based Forms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 + 9. Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 + 10. References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 + 11. Security Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 + 12. Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 + 13. Author's Address . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 + 14. Full Copyright Statement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 + +1. Terms + + Application Configuration Access Protocol (ACAP) -- An Internet + protocol (RFC-2244) that provides remote storage and access of + configuration and preference information. + + Activation -- A process in which a mobile station and network become + programmed so that a mobile station becomes operable and can be used + for cellular service once authorized by the service provider. + + Authentication -- A procedure used to validate a mobile station's + identity. + + Authentication Center -- An entity that manages the authentication + information related to the mobile station. + + Authentication Key (A-key) -- A secret 64-bit pattern stored in the + mobile station. It is used to generate and update the mobile + station's shared secret data. The A-key is used in the + authentication process. + + Authorization -- An action by a service provider to make cellular + service available to a subscriber. + + Call -- A temporary communication between telecommunications users + for the purpose of exchanging information. A call includes the + sequence of events that allocates and assigns resources and + signaling channels required to establish a communications + connection. + + Cellular Service Provider -- A licensee of the responsible + government agency (in the U.S. a licensee of the Federal + Communications Commission) authorized to provide Cellular + Radiotelephone Service. + + Challenge/Response Authentication Mechanism using Message Digest 5 + (CRAM-MD5) -- An authentication mechanism which is easy to + implement, and provides reasonable security against various attacks, + including replay. Supported in a variety of Internet protocols. + Specified as baseline mechanism in ACAP. CRAM-MD5 is published as + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 3] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + RFC 2195. + + Code Division Multiple Access -- A technique for spread-spectrum + multiple-access digital communications that creates channels through + the use of unique code sequences. + + Customer Service Center -- An entity of a service provider that + provides user support and assistance to subscribers. + + Customer Service Representative -- A person that operates from a + customer service center and provides user support and assistance to + subscribers. + + Diffie-Hellman Algorithm -- A public-key cryptography algorithm for + exchanging secret keys. Uses the equation , where k is the secret + key. The equation is executed by each party of the session based on + the exchange of independently generated public values. + + Digits -- Digits consist of the decimal integers 0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8, + and 9. + + Dual-mode Mobile Station -- A mobile station capable of both analog + and digital operation. + + Electronic Serial Number (ESN) -- A 32-bit number assigned by the + mobile station manufacturer used to identify a mobile station. The + ESN is unique for each legitimate mobile station. + + Home Location Registry (HLR) -- The location register or database to + which a MIN is assigned for record purposes such as subscriber + information. + + Message Digest 5 (MD5) -- A one-way cryptographic hash function. + Widely deployed in Internet protocols. Published as RFC 1321. + + Mobile Identification Number (MIN) -- The 10-digit number that + represents a mobile station's directory number. + + Mobile Station (MS) -- A station, fixed or mobile, which serves as + the end user's wireless communications link with the base station. + Mobile stations include portable units (e.g., hand-held personal + units) and units installed in vehicles. + + Mobile Switching Center (MSC) -- A configuration of equipment that + provides cellular radiotelephone service. + + Mobile Terminal Authorizing System (MTAS) -- A control system that + provides the capability to load the CDMA network HLR with mobile + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 4] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + station profile information. + + Number Assignment Module (NAM) -- The mobile station's electronic + memory module where the MIN and other subscriber-specific parameters + are stored. Mobile stations that have multi-NAM features offer + users the option of using their units in several different markets + by registering with a local number in each location. + + Over-the-air Service Provisioning Function (OTAF) -- A configuration + of network equipment that controls OTASP functionality and messaging + protocol. + + Over-the-air Parameter Administration (OTAPA) -- Network initiated + OTASP process of provisioning mobile station operational parameters + over the air interface. + + Over-the-air Service Provisioning (OTASP) -- A process of + provisioning mobile station operational parameters over the air + interface. + + Quick-Net-Connect (QNC) -- An IS-707 data service capability that + utilizes the Async Data Service Option number but bypasses the modem + connection for a direct connection to an IP-based internet. + + Roamer -- A mobile station operating in a cellular system or network + other than the one from which service was subscribed. + + Simple Authentication and Security Layer (SASL) -- An Internet + protocol (RFC-2222) that provides a framework for negotiating + authentication and encryption mechanisms. + + Service Provider -- A company, organization, business, etc. which + sells, administers, maintains, and charges for the service. The + service provider may or may not be the provider of the network. + + Shared Secret Data (SSD) -- A 128-bit pattern stored in the mobile + station (in semi-permanent memory) and known by the network. The + A-key is used to generate the SSD at the network and in the mobile + station for comparison. + + Wireless Application Protocol (WAP) -- A set of network and + application protocols including a datagram protocol (WDP), Transport + Layer Security (WTLS), Transaction Protocol (WTP), Session Protocol + (WSP), and Application Environment (WAE), which use carrier-based + gateways to enable wireless devices to access Web resources. See + <http://www.wapforum.org> for specifications and details. + + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 5] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + +2. Feature Descriptions + +2.1. OTASP Feature Description + + The Over the Air Service Provisioning (OTASP) feature allows a + potential wireless service subscriber to activate new wireless + services, and allows an existing wireless subscriber to make + services changes without the intervention of a third party. OTASP + includes the following: + + * A way to establish a user profile. + + * "Over-The-Air" programming of a Number Assignment Module (NAM), + IMSI and Roaming Lists, including Data option parameters, and + optionally, service provider or manufacturer specific parameters + + (e.g., lock code, call timer). + + * An Authentication Key (A-key) Generation procedure. + + * A-key storage + +2.2. OTAPA Feature Description + + The Over-the-Air Parameter Administration (OTAPA) feature allows + wireless service providers to update a NAM, IMSI, and Roaming List + information in the mobile station remotely without the intervention + of a third party. This capability increases flexibility and reduces + costs for carriers involved with mass changes that affect every + handset, such as area-code splits. + + OTAPA includes the following: + + * Update a user's Number Assignment Module (NAM) + + * Update Data option parameters + + * Update service provider or manufacturer specific parameters (e.g., + Server address(es), lock code, call timer). + + * Update roaming lists + + + + + + + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 6] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + +3. Operation + +3.1. Initial Provisioning Activity + + A new subscriber needs to give the intended service provider + sufficient information (e.g., name, address, etc.) to prove credit- + worthiness and establish a record within the service provider's + billing system. In addition, the ESN of the mobile station needs to + be given to the provider. This may occur in three ways: + + Voice scenario -- A customer care representative collects credit + information during a voice conversation. This call is made from a + different phone (e.g., wired service) or is initiated using the IS- + 683A OTASP dialing scheme (i.e., *228xx). + + Once the user has been authorized, the customer care representative + creates a record in the CDMA network HLR, thus allowing use of the + CDMA network. In addition, a limited-time N-digit password is + created which is tied to the ESN. The choice of N (how many digits) + is up to the carrier (as a trade-off between security and user + inconvenience). All required provisioning information (including + the limited-time password) is loaded into the provisioning server. + + The user is then told to hang up and call a special number, of the + form *228 XX <N-digit password> SEND (the XX code is the same as + used in the initial voice call). This causes the mobile station to + initiate a provisioning session. + + The mobile station and the provisioning server authenticate, and all + required provisioning information is downloaded into the mobile + station. The user receives some form of notification once the + activity is complete. This notification can be an audible tone or a + text message on the mobile station display. (The form and content of + this notification can be part of the provisioning data downloaded by + the mobile station.) Once this initial provisioning activity is + complete the user has a fully authorized mobile station ready for + use. + + Forms scenario -- An interactive user interface is presented via a + browser on the mobile station. The subscriber fills in the + requested information. (Note that entering non-numeric data presents + some user interface challenges on many mobile devices.) + + A back-end server validates the information, and if possible, the + customer is authorized, a limited-time password is generated, HLR + and provisioning server records are created and the actual OTASP + operation begins. Otherwise, a voice call is made to a customer + care representative. + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 7] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + Desktop scenario -- The subscriber uses a desktop (or in-store + kiosk) web browser to contact the carrier, and enters the usual + personal information. + + The carrier's server validates the information, and if possible, the + customer is authorized, a limited-time password is generated, HLR + and provisioning server records are created, and the subscriber is + told to dial a special number on the handset. Once this code is + entered, the actual OTASP operation begins. Otherwise, the user is + asked to make a voice call to a customer care representative. + +3.2. OTASP for Authorized Users + + Users already authorized for use of the CDMA network can also + initiate provisioning activity. This could happen after being + directed to do so by a Customer Care representative, either from a + phone conversation or via mail notification. This type of OTASP + activity is needed in cases where the carrier desires to upgrade + CDMA parameters in the mobile stations or in cases where mobile + station troubleshooting is needed. + + This type of OTASP occurs in similar fashion to the initial OTASP + activity. The mobile station downloads the new provisioning + information in the same way. + +3.3 OTAPA Activity + + Typical OTAPA capability involves upgrading a large number of mobile + stations. OTAPA activity needs to be performed in a manner that + does not impose on revenue bearing CDMA network activity. OTAPA + operations are initiated at the customer care center. This can be + accomplished by queuing a notification to the mobile station (via + 1-way SMS or special caller-ID) after the provisioning server has + the updated configuration data. OTAPA activity will not occur until + the mobile station has acquired CDMA service on the carrier's + network and the notification has reached the mobile station. + + Alternatively, OTAPA can be handled by including a recheck interval + in the set of data used to provision the mobile station. When using + a low-overhead protocol, such as ACAP [ACAP], it is reasonable to + have a mobile station check in periodically to see if anything has + changed. The time of day and/or day of week that such rechecks + should occur could be included in the provisioning data. + + OTAPA activity can be terminated at any time due to user call + activity. + + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 8] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + +4. Requirements + +4.1. General Requirements + + IS-683A OTASP operations occur between a mobile station and an + over-the-air service provisioning function (OTAF) using IS-95A + traffic channel data burst messages. OTASP/OTAPA via data services + require that the CDMA carrier have an IS-707 data services capable + network. The IS-707 service must be either Packet Data Service + (IS-707.5) or Quick-Net-Connect (QNC). + + The mobile station must support: + + * IS-707 Data Service capability + + * Packet/QNC RLP protocol + + * PPP protocol to peer to the IS-707 IWF + + * IP protocol to provide the network layer for routing to the + provisioning server + + * A transport layer for end-to-end communication (such as TCP) + + * Authentication and optionally encryption + + * Application software to handle the provisioning protocol and + memory access. + + * Domain Name System (DNS) query capabilities sufficient to obtain + the (IP) address of the provisioning server (or the provisioning + server's address could be provided during PPP negotiation). + + Lastly, the ability must exist for the mobile to make a data call + (optionally) a voice call without a MIN. + +4.2. OTASP Requirements + + The OTASP function requires the mobile station to originate an IS- + 707 data call and (optionally) a voice call using a completely + unprovisioned mobile station. The CDMA network must support this + capability. + + OTASP via data services uses a provisioning server that contains the + parameter information for mobile stations. The authorizing agent + (or software) at the customer care center must be able to add user + and mobile station information into both the CDMA network HLR and + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 9] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + the provisioning server during the initial authorizing process. The + provisioning server must be capable of servicing a mobile as soon as + its record is created. + +4.3. OTAPA Requirements + + IS-683A OTAPA is performed by a mobile-terminated call that + downloads parameters to the mobile station. OTAPA calls occur + without user interaction. + + In order to perform OTAPA via data services the network needs to + direct the mobile station to initiate a special-purpose data call. + Several existing methods can be used to implement this capability, + for example, a mobile-terminated one-way SMS message. The SMS + message content can contain any information required by the mobile + station. The mobile station would need a simple parser of SMS + messages in order to know when to originate an OTAPA call, as + opposed to normal SMS message processing. The OTAPA call would be + performed in similar fashion to a registration call. More + specifically, the user would not be informed of the call activity. + + There are alternative means that can be employed to initiate OTAPA + activity; for example, a mobile-terminated voice call with caller-ID + using a specialized telephone number. Another alternative is for + mobile stations to periodically check in with the provisioning + server to check for updated information. ACAP, for example, is + designed for such a model. The recheck interval, as well as the + time of day and/or day of week that such checks should be used, can + be part of the provisioning data sent to the mobile stations. + +4.4. Provisioning Server Requirements + + IS-683A utilizes an over-the-air service provisioning function + (OTAF) to perform the network-side provisioning activity. + OTASP/OTAPA via data services replaces the OTAF with a provisioning + server. The provisioning server resides on an IP network within the + controlled confines of the carrier. The provisioning server must + perform all the service provisioning and parameter administration + functions that the OTAF provides. The provisioning server must also + have an interface to the carrier's Mobile Terminal Authorizing + System (MTAS). This interface serves to synchronize the + provisioning server with the information in the MTAS. The specific + requirements of this interface depend on the capabilities and + interfaces of the carrier's customer care center system(s). The + provisioning server must be capable of receiving dynamic updates + from the MTAS and have the provisioning information immediately + + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 10] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + available for downloading into the chosen mobile station. A + standard ACAP server provides an excellent means to meet these + requirements. + + The provisioning server must be capable of performing an + authentication procedure with the mobile station. This + authentication mechanism must be capable of authenticating both the + mobile station and the provisioning server. + +4.5. Security Requirements + + OTASP requires that an authentication procedure be performed to + validate the mobile station to the provisioning server, while OTAPA + requires a mechanism where the mobile validates the server. + + The provisioning server must be capable of either: + + * OTAF A-key generation using a Diffie-Hellman mechanism + + Or: + + * Receiving A-keys from the carrier network. + + Since data OTASP/OTAPA operates over IP within the carrier's + network, end-to-end encryption between the mobile station and the + provisioning server should be considered as a future enhancement. + End-to-end encryption protects against attacks from within a + carrier's network, and safeguards the provisioning data (for + example, roaming lists). + +5. Architecture + +5.1. ACAP over TCP/IP + + Figure 1 shows a provisioning server in the carrier's intranet which + supports the Application Configuration Access Protocol (ACAP, RFC + 2244). An administrative client in the customer care domain updates + this server using ACAP. Handsets are provisioned and configured + using a small ACAP client. + + [Figure 1 -- see PostScript version] + + ACAP is an open Internet protocol designed to solve the problem of + client access to configuration and related data. Among its primary + goals are protocol simplicity, support for thin clients, and ease of + operation over limited bandwidth. ACAP provides a high degree of + extensibility, especially in authentication mechanisms, specialized + attribute handling, and data management. + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 11] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + +5.1.1. Mobile Authentication and A-Key Generation + + The mobile client authenticates with the ACAP server prior to + performing any activities. Authentication uses the mobile's ESN and + a shared secret. Provisioned mobiles derive the shared secret from + the A-Key; unprovisioned mobiles use a limited-time password as the + secret. + + The limited-time password is provided to the user by the Customer + Care representative during the initial call (as instructions to dial + a specific number). This code is N digits long. The carrier + selects the number of digits, as a trade-off between security and + user convenience. + + The baseline ACAP authentication mechanism uses the shared secret + plus a random challenge from the server as input to a one-way + cryptographic hash function (specifically, keyed-MD5). This is + analogous to the existing IS-683A authentication mechanism which + uses a random challenge and the CAVE algorithm. + + An A-Key is generated using a Diffie-Hellman exchange, as is done in + IS-683A. + +5.1.2. Mobile Identification + + Provisioning records are identified using the ESN and the current + NAM in use. + +5.1.3. ACAP Server + + As a standard ACAP server, the provisioning server includes + configurable datasets and dataset inheritance for the management of + the data stores. + + The administrative client can use the same simple ACAP protocol to + load and modify the ACAP server as the mobile stations uses for + provisioning. While any implementation-specific mechanisms + available from the server vendor could instead be used for this + purpose, the ability to use ACAP can greatly simplify the + administrative client, as well as make it independent of the server. + + ACAP includes an authentication framework (Simple Authentication and + Security Layer, SASL, RFC 2222)[SASL]. SASL allows any standard or + custom authentication and encryption mechanism to be used. One of + the most important features of SASL is that it is designed for a + world in which what is "good enough" security today isn't good + enough tomorrow. As the threat model changes, SASL allows higher- + strength mechanisms to be easily added while supporting already + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 12] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + deployed clients and servers. SASL is achieving widespread + deployment in a number of Internet protocols. + + Strongpoints: Since the ACAP protocol was designed for precisely + this type of provisioning activity, its adoption can greatly reduce + the cost, time to market, and support required for the provisioning + server. Additionally, the ACAP protocol provides an open standard + method for mobile stations and other systems to access the + provisioning server. Commercial ACAP servers are being developed by + numerous companies. The ACAP client code is very small and simple, + and thus can be incorporated into virtually any mobile device at + minimal cost. As an open standard, the ACAP protocol has benefited + from years of review and experience. + +5.1.4. Overview of ACAP Structure + + ACAP organizes data by datasets. The structure of a dataset is + defined by the dataset class. Generally, ACAP servers do not have + knowledge of dataset classes. This allows the dataset to be + expanded without modifying the server in any way. A dataset is an + instantiation of the dataset class, which is a logical definition of + what is in a dataset, and how it is used. + + Datasets contain entries. Entries contain attributes and values. + Attributes and values are actually metadata, such as name, length, + and value. Any entry can also be a dataset (datasets are + hierarchical). + + For example, consider the ACAP addressbook dataset class, designed + to hold names, email addresses, phone numbers, and related + information for a person's contacts. A given user may have one or + more addressbook datasets. Each entry holds information about one + person or entity. Attributes in the entry hold specific items of + information, such as the given name, surname, various email + addresses, phone numbers, and so forth. If an entry is a list of + people (such as a mailing list or specific group of people), it is a + subdataset, containing its own entries. Some clients may look at + only a subset of the attributes. For example, a mobile handset ACAP + client may download only the alias (nickname), name, primary phone + number and email address of each entry, while a desktop client may + access all attributes. + +5.1.5. Data Organization and Capabilities + + ACAP provides custom hierarchical datasets. Server data can be + organized to fit the needs of the applications using the dataset. + + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 13] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + In OTASP/OTAPA over ACAP, data on the server is organized to both + take advantage of ACAP capabilities and to use items that are + identical to IS-683A, allowing for reuse of IS-683A handset engines. + + ACAP servers also support data inheritance. All data items which + are physically in the inherited dataset and not in the inheriting + dataset logically also exist in the inheriting dataset. This is + recursive, as the inherited dataset can itself inherit from another + dataset. This powerful concept allows potentially large groups of + mobile stations to inherit items from a single common entity. For + example, preferred roaming lists can be stored in datasets based on + geographic areas, and automatically inherited by an individual + mobile station in that area. The roaming lists could be further + subdivided, for example based on tiers of free NVRAM in the mobile. + The mobile client need not be aware of this; it happens entirely on + the server. + + ACAP uses trees to provide the data hierarchy. These data trees can + be viewed as similar to the directory/file structure used with all + common operating systems. The built-in inheritance mechanism, + together with the hierarchical structure, makes it extremely easy to + update general data without disturbing specific data. + + Datasets exist within the user, group, and host hierarchies. The + user hierarchy holds datasets which belong to individual users. The + group hierarchy holds datasets which belong to groups (for example, + the "Region." groups in section 5.1.6.3 Server Roaming Lists). The + host hierarchy holds datasets which are for specific machines or + systems. + + In addition to providing customizable data trees, ACAP also provides + several standard datasets for all clients. There is a capabilities + dataset that contains information on custom functionality and + enhanced features available to a specific client or at the site + generally. This allows a server to advertise any protocol + extensions, specialized attribute handling, or other enhanced + functionality it supports. A client that needs to use these + features can thus easily determine what is available before trying + to use them. + +5.1.5.1. Structure + + We divide the data accessed by the client into provisioning items, + group items, and client state items. Provisioning data contains NAM + items and requested-data items. Group items (such as preferred + roaming lists), are not specific to any mobile device. Group items + physically exist in their own datasets, but through inheritance + logically appear in client datasets. + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 14] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + The mobile stations always read data from provisioning entries and + write data to client state entries. This structure makes both + mobile clients and server configuration easy and simple, while + allowing for extensive custom and diagnostic capabilities. + +5.1.5.2. Conventions + + "" This signifies the empty string (used here for ACAP entries). + + ~ This is shorthand for "user/<userid>". It is part of the ACAP + protocol. + +5.1.6 Dataset + + Provisioning information is located in the "OTAP" dataset class. + (The full specification of this dataset will be published in a + subsequent document.) The prefix "Provision." is used for items that + are to be downloaded to the mobile, and the prefix "Client." is used + for items which the client stores on the server. + + Provisioning data within the OTAP dataset is organized as a series + of items, each of which is stored in its own entry. The entry name + is the item name, and the "OTAP.VALUE" attribute contains the item + value. This structure permits change notification on a per-item + basis. + + We chose the "Provision" and "Client" names to simplify various + operations. For example, the mobile client can easily download all + changed provisioning items by performing a search which returns the + "OTAP.VALUE" attribute of all entries whose name begins with + "Provision" and whose modtime is greater than the last time the + client retrieved data. An administrative client can easily generate + a report of all clients which have not received the most recent + update by searching for all entries named "Client" whose + "OTAP.modtime" attribute is less than the desired value. + + A partial list of items follows. + +5.1.6.1. Entries and Attributes + + dataset.inherit + + This is a standard ACAP attribute that identifies the location of + inherited data. It exists in the "" entry (the entry with the empty + name) within each dataset. + + + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 15] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + +5.1.6.2. NAM Records + + The OTAP dataset class contains an entry for each provisioned + mobile. The standard location for provisioning records is: + + /OTAP/USER/<esn>/<nam>/ + + This tree format allows multiple NAMs per ESN. The specific entries + contain data in IS-683A parameter block types. + + For example, the CDMA NAM would be stored in an entry called: + + /OTAP/USER/<esn>/<nam>/Provision.CDMA-NAM/ + + The entries below show how NAM records would be organized on the + ACAP server: + + CDMA/Analog NAM + + Entry-Path: /OTAP/USER/<esn>/<nam>/Provision.CDMA-AMPS-NAM/ + + OTAP.Value: {17} xx xx xx ... xx + + The CDMA/Analog NAM entry from IS-683A (section 4.5.2.1) + consists of at least 129 information bits, depending on the + number of SID NID list entries. This is stored as 17 (or more) + octets of binary data (padding is used to ensure an integral + number of octets). + + Mobile Directory Number + + Entry-Path: /OTAP/USER/<esn>/<nam>/Provision.MOBILE-DN/ + + OTAP.Value: {10} nnnnnnnnnn + + The Mobile Directory Number from IS-683A contains BCD-encoded + digits representing the phone number. This is stored as a + string of 10 or more ASCII digits, e.g., "6195551212". + + CDMA NAM + + Entry-Path: /OTAP/USER/<esn>/<nam>/ Provision.CDMA-NAM/ + + OTAP.Value: {13} xx xx xx ... xx + + + + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 16] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + The CDMA-NAM entry from IS-683A (section 4.5.2.3) consists of at + least 100 information bits, depending on the number of SID-NID + list entries. This is stored as 13 (or more) octets of binary + data (padding is used to ensure an integral number of octets). + + IMSI_T + + Entry-Path: /OTAP/USER/<esn>/<nam>/ Provision.IMSI_T/ + + OTAP.Value: {7} xx xx xx xx xx xx xx + + The IMSI_T entry from IS-683A (section 4.5.2.4) consists of 55 + bits of information in five fields. This is stored left- + justified in 7 octets of binary data. + +5.1.6.3. Server Roaming Lists + + The ACAP Server will have an entry for each different roaming list + configuration for a carrier. The example below assumes that the + desired differentiation for the roaming list is geographic, with + subdivisions for tiers of mobile free NVRAM It shows that for each + region there exists a set of roaming lists per free NVRAM range. + Note that a carrier can easily implement different or further + differentiation (e.g., by phone vendor or product type) by simply + changing the dataset tree and assigned the appropriate value to the + "dataset.inherit" attribute in the provisioning records. + + /OTAP/GROUP/region.NorthEast/free-nv.128-512/ + preferred.roaming.list/OTAP.Value + /OTAP/GROUP/region.NorthEast/free-nv.512-1024/ + preferred.roaming.list/OTAP.Value + /OTAP/GROUP/region.SouthEast/free-nv.128-512/ + preferred.roaming.list/OTAP.Value + /OTAP/GROUP/region.SouthEast/free-nv.512-1024/ + preferred.roaming.list/OTAP.Value + /OTAP/GROUP/region.NorthWest/free-nv.128-512/ + preferred.roaming.list/OTAP.Value + /OTAP/GROUP/region.NorthWest/free-nv.512-1024/ + preferred.roaming.list/OTAP.Value + /OTAP/GROUP/region.SouthWest/free-nv.128-512/ + preferred.roaming.list/OTAP.Value + /OTAP/GROUP/region.SouthWest/free-nv.512-1024/ + preferred.roaming.list/OTAP.Value + + + + + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 17] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + +5.1.6.4. Requested-Data Record + + Inside the OTAP dataset is an entry with the name + "Provision.Requested-Data", which contains one attribute called + "OTAP.Requested-Data". This attribute is multi-valued. It is + either NIL or contains a list of strings. Each string is the name + of one element of data that the server requests the client to + supply. + + After authenticating, the ACAP client issues a SEARCH command to + retrieve the values of the "OTAP.Requested-Data" attribute of the + "Provision.Requested-Data" entry. The client processes the returned + values (if any) by issuing a STORE command to set one or more + attributes in the "Client" entry. The value of each attribute is + either the corresponding mobile value (which may be an empty string + if the item has no value), or the special value "[N/A]" if the item + does not exist or is unknown on the mobile. + + This mechanism is quite general, and can be used in the normal OTASP + case to modify the mobile's dataset as appropriate for the condition + of the mobile. For example, the inheritance could be set based on + the amount of NVRAM available, to cause one set of preferred roaming + list data or another to be used. This mechanism can also be used in + other situations, such as to retrieve a complete set of mobile + configuration parameters for diagnostic reasons. + +5.1.6.5. Sample Server Entry + + The entry below is an excerpt of a sample ACAP server dataset entry + for a single mobile station, with an ESN of FB9876E and using NAM 1: + + /OTAP/USER/FB9876E/1/ + + entry = "" + dataset.inherit = "/OTAP/GROUP/region.NorthEast/ + free-nv.128-512/preferred.roaming.list/ + OTAP.Value/" + + entry = "Provision.Requested-Data" + OTAP.Requested-Data = ("Phone-Make" "Phone-Model" "SW-Rev" + "Free-NVRAM") + + entry = "Client" + OTAP.Phone-Make = "Qualcomm" + OTAP.Phone-Model = "pdQ1900" + OTAP.SW-Rev = "001.030.0908" + OTAP.Free-NVRAM = "65536" + OTAP.Last-Modtime = "199812181703" + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 18] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + entry = "Provision.Mobile-DN" + OTAP.Value = {10} 619 555 1234 + + entry = "Provision.CDMA-NAM" + OTAP.Value = {13} xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx + xx xx + + This dataset shows not only provisioning data which was downloaded + into the mobile station, but also the items of client data requested + by the server (the Requested-Data attribute) and the values of those + items (the "Client" entry). It also indicates that the mobile + client successfully stored the values associated with the modtime + "199812181703". In addition, it shows that this client inherits + data (i.e., roaming lists) from the "NorthEast" region. + +5.1.7. Administrative Client + + The administrative client loads initial provisioning information + into the server, including specifying the roaming list to inherit. + The administrative client also updates provisioning server records + as needed, and retrieves data for reports (such as a list of clients + which have not yet been updated). + + Data is loaded into provisioning records by using the ACAP STORE + command. The administrative client authenticates to the ACAP server + using credentials that permit access to datasets for mobiles. + + When a new mobile is authorized for service, the administrative + client creates the dataset by storing into it values that are + specific for the device. It also sets the "dataset.inherit" + attribute so that values which are not tied to the specific mobile + are inherited as appropriate. + + * Updates to user records + + Existing user records may need updating from time to time. For + example, a user may change service plans or purchase an + additional or replacement mobile device, or the carrier may + need to modify some aspect of provisioned data. + + * Perusal and editing of provisioning records + + The administrative client can provide general browse and edit + capability for user records. + + + + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 19] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + * Report generation + + The administrative client can extract data from the ACAP server + in order to generate reports. For example, after OTAPA + activity, a carrier may wish to identify those mobiles which + have not yet been updated. + + * Queuing of OTAPA sessions + + Depending on the OTAPA update procedures chosen (e.g., SMS, + CLID, periodic recheck), the administrative client may be + involved in initiating the activity. This may or may not use + an interface to the provisioning server. + +5.1.8. Mobile Client + + The ACAP mobile client is implemented as a state machine that + performs the equivalent of IS-683A provisioning parameter + information exchange and non-volatile memory storage. The ACAP + Client state machine diagram (Figure 2) and descriptions are below. + + [Figure 2 -- see PostScript version] + + * Establish Transport Layer/Authenticate + + Authentication and/or encryption can occur at the application + layer and/or at the network/transport layer. + + Basic ACAP authentication occurs in the application layer + (i.e., within the ACAP session), and in its baseline form uses + the CRAM-MD5[CRAM-MD5] mechanism. If desired, other mechanisms + can be used which provide more protection and encryption. This + occurs after the transport layer is established, as shown in + the client state machine diagram above + + Figure 3 shows the CRAM-MD5 authentication mechanism for an + unprovisioned mobile. In the case of provisioned mobiles, the + shared secret is derived from the A-Key, instead of the + limited-time N-digit code used for unprovisioned devices. + + Use of basic ACAP authentication is preferred for initial + implementations of data-OTASP because it is simple, easy to + implement, and all procedures and methods are in place. + Stronger SASL mechanisms and/or IPSec can be rolled out in the + future without disrupting the deployed base. + + [Figure 3 -- see PostScript version] + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 20] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + * Requested-data SEARCH + + The mobile ACAP client issues a search command asking the + server to return the attribute "OTAP.Requested-Data" in the + entry "Requested-Data". + + * Receive requested-data values + + The server instructs the client to store attributes by + returning one or more values of requested-data in response to + the Requested-Data SEARCH. + + For example, the attribute "OTAP.Requested-Data" in the entry + "Requested-Data" might contain four values: "phone-make", + "phone-model", "SW-Rev", and "Free-NVRAM". + + * STORE attribute list + + If the response to the requested-data SEARCH returns any + values, the client issues a STORE command. Each attribute in + the STORE command corresponds to one item of requested-data. + If the client does not recognize an item, it stores the string + "[n/a]". + + Continuing with our example, the client uses this STORE command + to write four attributes into the "Client" entry. Each + attribute name is identical to one value of the + OTAP.Requested-Data" attribute (with the prefix "OTAP." added). + Each attribute value is determined by the respective mobile + value. + + In our example, this STORE command sets the following + attributes and values: + + - "OTAP.Phone-Make" = "Qualcomm + - "OTAP.Phone-Model" = "pdQ1900 + - "OTAP.SW-Rev" = "001.030.0908" + - "OTAP.Free-NVRAM" = "65536" + + * Provisioning data SEARCH + + The mobile ACAP client issues a search command to retrieve any + items of provisioning data that have changed since it last + checked in (which in the initial session retrieves all + provisioning data). + + + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 21] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + This SEARCH command asks the server to return the "OTAP.Value" + attribute of any entries whose name starts with "provision." + (case-insensitive) and whose modtime is greater than the + supplied value (which is zero for an unprovisioned mobile). + + * Receive provisioning data and modtime + + The server returns the provisioning items, each as one entry + name and one attribute value. The server response to the + SEARCH command includes the modtime of the latest entry + returned. + + * Save values + + The mobile writes the returned values into NVRAM. + + * STORE modtime + + The ACAP client stores the returned modtime on the server as an + acknowledgement that the data was received and NVRAM updated. + + * LOGOUT + + The client issues the LOGOUT command. + + * Close transport layer + + The client closes the TCP connection. + + * End call + + The data call is terminated. + +5.2. WAP with ACAP + + An advantage of the ACAP solution is that is can easily coexist with + a WAP-based mechanism, giving carriers more options. + + A carrier can deploy handsets into its service area which use WAP- + based provisioning, if desired, alongside those which use ACAP + provisioning. All that is required is that the WAP server contain a + small ACAP client (or an interface to an ACAP server). + + Figure 4 shows how mobile stations can be configured using a WAP + browser. By using an ACAP server for provisioning, carriers are + free to simultaneously deploy mobile stations that use either WAP or + ACAP, as desired. In either case, the ACAP server is the source for + provisioning data. + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 22] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + [Figure 4 -- see PostScript version] + +5.3. Network-Resident vs. Configuration Data + + It is useful to recognize that wireless devices access two different + types of carrier-provided data: network-resident and configuration. + Network-resident data exists primarily within the carrier's network. + Examples include account status, billing detail, service plan + options, etc. While mobiles may access this information for user + display, it resides in the network. Configuration data, in + contrast, affects the operation of the handset, is usually not shown + to the user, and must persist in the device. + + For network-resident data access, the obvious choice is the web. + The data is highly interactive and time-variant, making web browsers + a reasonable solution. Any appropriate web browser can be used. + There are many good reasons for having a web browser in a wireless + device which contains a display and is capable of user interaction. + + For configuration data, the best solution is to use ACAP. ACAP is + optimized for the job, can be implemented quickly, requires a very + small amount of memory, and does not depend on a display or any user + interaction capability. + + Trying to use the same access method for both types of data + unnecessarily complicates the solution, leading to increased design, + development, and debug time and expense. It makes it more difficult + to offer low-cost devices. Since the two types of data + fundamentally differ, it is good engineering practice to select + optimal code and protocols for each. + +5.4. Intellectual Property Issues + + There are no known intellectual property issues with the ACAP + solution. The ACAP specification was developed within the IETF, and + no ownership, patent, or other IP claims have been asserted. + Multiple independent vendors are developing ACAP clients and + servers, in addition to the existing usage in deployed products. + +6. Handset Protocol Suites + +6.1. ACAP over TCP/IP + + Figure 5 depicts the mobile station protocol suite for the ACAP over + TCP/IP solution. The mobile station is capable of supporting both + IS-683A OTASP and OTASP over ACAP. + + [Figure 5 -- see PostScript version] + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 23] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + +7. IS-683A Compatibility + +7.1. OTASP Operations + + To maximize compatibility and allow for reuse of IS-683A handset + code, the data formats used in OTASP over ACAP are identical to + those used in IS-683A. Section 5.1.5 Data Organization and + Capabilities discusses this in more detail. + + OTASP via IS-683A requires custom design and development for the + specific CDMA infrastructure used by a carrier. This can greatly + limit the data management capabilities and significantly reduces the + extensibility of the solution. Conversely, OTASP over data can be + implemented on a generic IP network using an Internet standards- + based capability that provides extensible provisioning activities + for carriers. + + OTASP over data uses a traffic channel whereas IS-683A OTASP runs + over the limited-bandwidth signaling channel. + + IS-683A OTASP operations are inherently simultaneous voice and data. + This allows the customer care representative to extract information + from the mobile station while conversing with the user. OTASP over + data services is a data-only solution (at least for now). This + makes OTASP operations slightly more sequential and potentially + problematic. Simultaneous voice and data will alleviate this issue. + +7.2 OTASP Call Flow + + The call flow diagram (Figure 6) depicts the message sequence and + operations for a typical IS-683A OTASP (provisioning) call. Any + data-OTASP solution must perform all the functions of the IS-683A + OTASP call. The proposed solution meets these requirements. + + [Figure 6 -- see PostScript version] + +7.3. OTAPA Operations + + Data-OTAPA requires the ability to instruct mobiles to originate a + data call to the provisioning server. Several viable approaches are + discussed in sections 3.3 OTAPA Activity and 4.3 OTAPA + Requirements. + + OTAPA over data has the potential to require far less channel + resources to download new information to mobile stations. The ACAP + server inherently only communicates changes to the clients, thus + only changed information needs to be downloaded to the mobile + stations using OTAPA over data via ACAP. + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 24] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + +7.4. OTAPA Call Flow + + The call flow diagram (Figure 7) depicts the message sequence for a + typical IS-683A OTAPA operation. Any data-OTAPA solution must + perform all the functions of the IS-683A OTAPA call. The proposed + solution meets these requirements. + + [Figure 7 -- see PostScript version] + +8. Alternative Methods + +8.1. IS-683A over TCP/IP + + One alternative is to port IS-683A to TCP, remaining as close as + possible to the IS-683A protocol exchange. + + Figure 8 depicts the architecture and communications backbone to + support OTASP/OTAPA via IS-707 data services with a provisioning + server based on the IS-683A OTAF function. + + [Figure 8 -- see PostScript version] + +8.1.1. OTAF Server + + This provisioning server is modeled after the IS-683A OTAF. The + OTAF server performs the specific operations and messaging of IS- + 683A OTAF. This includes A-key reauthentication procedures. + + Strongpoints: + + (1) OTAF and mobile station behavior mirrors IS-683A (reduced + duplicate software in mobile station). Nearly all procedures fully + defined. + + Drawbacks: + + (1) The OTAF server would need to be custom-designed and built. + + (2) No inherent data manipulation capabilities in the OTAF server. + All required or desired data management activities would have to be + built from scratch. + + (3) Interface application would require a non-standard interface + (and therefore proprietary) to OTAF server. + + (4) End-to-end encryption scheme still needed for full security. + + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 25] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + +8.1.2. Interface Application + + This function loads all required provisioning-related information + from the CDMA network information system to the OTAF server. This + includes the queuing of provisioning transactions and data. + + +8.1.3. Protocol Handset Suite + + Figure 9 depicts the mobile station protocol suite for the IS-683A + over TCP/IP solution. The OTASP client is capable of supporting + both IS-683A OTASP activities or OTASP activities over the data + transport. + + [Figure 9 -- see PostScript version] + +8.2. Browser-Based Forms + + Another alternative is to use forms embedded in web pages. + + Encapsulating the provisioning data into custom tags embedded in a + web form is an idea that at first seems attractive. There are a lot + of advantages in having a browser in the handset, web servers are + very widely deployed, and everyone is familiar on some level with + the web. + + However, a meta-protocol for this would need to be designed, and a + fully detailed specification produced. This solution requires + custom software on the provider side to handle the meta-protocol. + It additionally requires handset vendors to add custom software in + the handset browser to handle this protocol. + + This solution would require a provisioning-capable browser in every + phone. While it may be desirable to have a browser, the decision to + require it needs to be considered carefully, especially in light of + the memory requirements it would impose on all devices. + + This solution would complicate the handset browser, by requiring it + to handle provisioning as well as browsing. As provisioning and + browsing are functionally dissimilar, this code is not a natural fit + within the browser. Implementing this solution would require a + significant increase in development and debug resources, and thus + negatively impact time-to-market and cost. + + Also because the web is functionally dissimilar, a high level of + carrier-side customization would be needed, leading to reduced + vendor choice and increased deployment costs. + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 26] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + + This approach would layer custom data on top of a standard protocol. + This would require design work, and would not have much time for + open review before deployment, greatly increasing the risk. By + contrast, ACAP has had years of open review and refinement. + + This approach also limits the extensibility of the solution. ACAP, + conversely, is very extensible. Because ACAP is such a simple + protocol, it can be added to a wide variety of applications at low + cost. This allows increasing numbers of applications on the mobile + device to share information with servers as well as desktop + applications. + +9. Conclusion + + ACAP provides a high degree of extensibility, especially in + authentication mechanisms, custom attribute handling, and data + management. By using an Internet standard protocol, + interoperability and integration with a variety of equipment is + possible, and carriers are not locked into any vendor. It is also + easier to add new levels of service and capabilities, especially + integration with future subscriber devices and applications (e.g., + email). + + Since an ACAP client is so small, it can be incorporated into + virtually any device, even low-end ones without displays, and can be + added without sacrificing other features. The simplicity of the + client and protocol directly translate to shorter development cycles + and faster time-to-market. + + Because the ACAP protocol was designed for precisely this type of + provisioning activity, its adoption can greatly reduce the cost, + time to market, and support required for the provisioning server as + well as the handsets. As an open standard, the ACAP protocol has + benefited from years of review and experience. + + Another advantage of the ACAP solution is that is can easily coexist + with a WAP-based mechanism, giving carriers more options and + reducing the minimal requirement burden on mobile devices. + + A carrier can deploy handsets into its service area which use WAP- + based provisioning, if desired, alongside those which use ACAP + provisioning. By using an ACAP server for provisioning, carriers + are free to simultaneously deploy mobile stations that use either + WAP or ACAP, as desired. + + The lack of intellectual-property issues further adds to ACAP's + appeal. + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 27] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + +10. References + + [ACAP] Newman, C. and J. Myers, "ACAP -- Application Configuration + Access Protocol", RFC 2244, November 1997. + + [CRAM-MD5] Klensin, J., Catoe, R. and P. Krumviede, "IMAP/POP + AUTHorize Extension for Simple Challenge/Response", RFC 2195, + September 1997. + + [SASL] Myers, J., "Simple Authentication and Security Layer (SASL)", + RFC 2222, October 1997. + +11. Security Considerations + + Security is discussed in many sections of this document. In + particular, the need and methods to guard against unauthorized + updating of handsets, usurpation of newly-created accounts, + compromise of handset security values, and disclosure of carrier + proprietary data and handset parameters is covered. + +12. Acknowledgments + + Jim Willkie and Marc Phillips contributed greatly to this document. + Their help is very much appreciated. + +13. Author's Address + + Randall Gellens + QUALCOMM Incorporated + 6455 Lusk Boulevard + San Diego, CA 92121-2779 + + Phone: +1 619 651 5115 + EMail: randy@qualcomm.com + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 28] + +RFC 2604 OTASP/OTAPA via ACAP June 1999 + + +14. Full Copyright Statement + + Copyright (C) The Internet Society (1999). All Rights Reserved. + + This document and translations of it may be copied and furnished to + others, and derivative works that comment on or otherwise explain it + or assist in its implementation may be prepared, copied, published + and distributed, in whole or in part, without restriction of any + kind, provided that the above copyright notice and this paragraph are + included on all such copies and derivative works. However, this + document itself may not be modified in any way, such as by removing + the copyright notice or references to the Internet Society or other + Internet organizations, except as needed for the purpose of + developing Internet standards in which case the procedures for + copyrights defined in the Internet Standards process must be + followed, or as required to translate it into languages other than + English. + + The limited permissions granted above are perpetual and will not be + revoked by the Internet Society or its successors or assigns. + + This document and the information contained herein is provided on an + "AS IS" basis and THE INTERNET SOCIETY AND THE INTERNET ENGINEERING + TASK FORCE DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING + BUT NOT LIMITED TO ANY WARRANTY THAT THE USE OF THE INFORMATION + HEREIN WILL NOT INFRINGE ANY RIGHTS OR ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF + MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. + +Acknowledgement + + Funding for the RFC Editor function is currently provided by the + Internet Society. + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +Gellens Informational [Page 29] + |