diff options
Diffstat (limited to 'doc/rfc/rfc3092.txt')
-rw-r--r-- | doc/rfc/rfc3092.txt | 787 |
1 files changed, 787 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/doc/rfc/rfc3092.txt b/doc/rfc/rfc3092.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9b9d171 --- /dev/null +++ b/doc/rfc/rfc3092.txt @@ -0,0 +1,787 @@ + + + + + + +Network Working Group D. Eastlake 3rd +Request for Comments: 3092 Motorola +Category: Informational C. Manros + Xerox + E. Raymond + Open Source Initiative + 1 April 2001 + + + Etymology of "Foo" + +Status of this Memo + + This memo provides information for the Internet community. It does + not specify an Internet standard of any kind. Distribution of this + memo is unlimited. + +Copyright Notice + + Copyright (C) The Internet Society (2001). All Rights Reserved. + +Abstract + + Approximately 212 RFCs so far, starting with RFC 269, contain the + terms `foo', `bar', or `foobar' as metasyntactic variables without + any proper explanation or definition. This document rectifies that + deficiency. + +Table of Contents + + 1. Introduction............................................1 + 2. Definition and Etymology................................2 + 3. Acronyms................................................5 + Appendix...................................................7 + Security Considerations...................................11 + References................................................12 + Authors' Addresses........................................13 + Full Copyright Statement..................................14 + +1. Introduction + + Approximately 212 RFCs, or about 7% of RFCs issued so far, starting + with [RFC269], contain the terms `foo', `bar', or `foobar' used as a + metasyntactic variable without any proper explanation or definition. + This may seem trivial, but a number of newcomers, especially if + English is not their native language, have had problems in + understanding the origin of those terms. This document rectifies + that deficiency. + + + +Eastlake, et al. Informational [Page 1] + +RFC 3092 Etymology of "Foo" 1 April 2001 + + + Section 2 below describes the definition and etymology of these words + and Section 3 interprets them as acronyms. + + As an Appendix, we include a table of RFC occurrences of these words + as metasyntactic variables. + +2. Definition and Etymology + + bar /bar/ n. [JARGON] + + 1. The second metasyntactic variable, after foo and before baz. + "Suppose we have two functions: FOO and BAR. FOO calls BAR...." + + 2. Often appended to foo to produce foobar. + + foo /foo/ + + 1. interj. Term of disgust. + + 2. Used very generally as a sample name for absolutely anything, esp. + programs and files (esp. scratch files). + + 3. First on the standard list of metasyntactic variables used in + syntax examples (bar, baz, qux, quux, corge, grault, garply, + waldo, fred, plugh, xyzzy, thud). [JARGON] + + When used in connection with `bar' it is generally traced to the + WW II era Army slang acronym FUBAR (`Fucked Up Beyond All + Repair'), later modified to foobar. Early versions of the Jargon + File [JARGON] interpreted this change as a post-war + bowdlerization, but it now seems more likely that FUBAR was itself + a derivative of `foo' perhaps influenced by German `furchtbar' + (terrible) - `foobar' may actually have been the original form. + + For, it seems, the word `foo' itself had an immediate prewar + history in comic strips and cartoons. In the 1938 Warner Brothers + cartoon directed by Robert Clampett, "The Daffy Doc", a very early + version of Daffy Duck holds up a sign saying "SILENCE IS FOO!" + `FOO' and `BAR' also occurred in Walt Kelly's "Pogo" strips. The + earliest documented uses were in the surrealist "Smokey Stover" + comic strip by Bill Holman about a fireman. This comic strip + appeared in various American comics including "Everybody's" + between about 1930 and 1952. It frequently included the word + "FOO" on license plates of cars, in nonsense sayings in the + background of some frames such as "He who foos last foos best" or + "Many smoke but foo men chew", and had Smokey say "Where there's + foo, there's fire". Bill Holman, the author of the strip, filled + it with odd jokes and personal contrivances, including other + + + +Eastlake, et al. Informational [Page 2] + +RFC 3092 Etymology of "Foo" 1 April 2001 + + + nonsense phrases such as "Notary Sojac" and "1506 nix nix". + According to the Warner Brothers Cartoon Companion [WBCC] Holman + claimed to have found the word "foo" on the bottom of a Chinese + figurine. This is plausible; Chinese statuettes often have + apotropaic inscriptions, and this may have been the Chinese word + `fu' (sometimes transliterated `foo'), which can mean "happiness" + when spoken with the proper tone (the lion-dog guardians flanking + the steps of many Chinese restaurants are properly called "fu + dogs") [PERS]. English speakers' reception of Holman's `foo' + nonsense word was undoubtedly influenced by Yiddish `feh' and + English `fooey' and `fool'. [JARGON, FOLDOC] + + Holman's strip featured a firetruck called the Foomobile that rode + on two wheels. The comic strip was tremendously popular in the + late 1930s, and legend has it that a manufacturer in Indiana even + produced an operable version of Holman's Foomobile. According to + the Encyclopedia of American Comics [EAC], `Foo' fever swept the + U.S., finding its way into popular songs and generating over 500 + `Foo Clubs.' The fad left `foo' references embedded in popular + culture (including the couple of appearances in Warner Brothers + cartoons of 1938-39) but with their origins rapidly forgotten. + [JARGON] + + One place they are known to have remained live is in the U.S. + military during the WWII years. In 1944-45, the term `foo + fighters' [FF] was in use by radar operators for the kind of + mysterious or spurious trace that would later be called a UFO (the + older term resurfaced in popular American usage in 1995 via the + name of one of the better grunge-rock bands [BFF]). Informants + connected the term to the Smokey Stover strip [PERS]. + + The U.S. and British militaries frequently swapped slang terms + during the war. Period sources reported that `FOO' became a + semi-legendary subject of WWII British-army graffiti more or less + equivalent to the American Kilroy [WORDS]. Where British troops + went, the graffito "FOO was here" or something similar showed up. + Several slang dictionaries aver that FOO probably came from + Forward Observation Officer, but this (like the contemporaneous + "FUBAR") was probably a backronym [JARGON]. Forty years later, + Paul Dickson's excellent book "Words" [WORDS] traced "Foo" to an + unspecified British naval magazine in 1946, quoting as follows: + + "Mr. Foo is a mysterious Second World War product, gifted with + bitter omniscience and sarcasm." + + Earlier versions of the Jargon File suggested the possibility that + hacker usage actually sprang from "FOO, Lampoons and Parody", the + title of a comic book first issued in September 1958, a joint + + + +Eastlake, et al. Informational [Page 3] + +RFC 3092 Etymology of "Foo" 1 April 2001 + + + project of Charles and Robert Crumb. Though Robert Crumb (then in + his mid-teens) later became one of the most important and + influential artists in underground comics, this venture was hardly + a success; indeed, the brothers later burned most of the existing + copies in disgust. The title FOO was featured in large letters on + the front cover. However, very few copies of this comic actually + circulated, and students of Crumb's `oeuvre' have established that + this title was a reference to the earlier Smokey Stover comics. + The Crumbs may also have been influenced by a short-lived Canadian + parody magazine named `Foo' published in 1951-52. [JARGON] + + An old-time member reports that in the 1959 "Dictionary of the + TMRC Language", compiled at TMRC (the Tech Model Railroad Club at + MIT) there was an entry for Foo. The current on-line version, in + which "Foo" is the only word coded to appear red, has the + following [TMRC]: + + Foo: The sacred syllable (FOO MANI PADME HUM); to be spoken + only when under obligation to commune with the Deity. Our first + obligation is to keep the Foo Counters turning. + + This definition used Bill Holman's nonsense word, then only two + decades old and demonstrably still live in popular culture and + slang, to make a "ha ha only serious" analogy with esoteric + Tibetan Buddhism. Today's hackers would find it difficult to + resist elaborating a joke like that, and it is not likely 1959's + were any less susceptible. [JARGON] + + 4. [EF] Prince Foo was the last ruler of Pheebor and owner of the + Phee Helm, about 400 years before the reign of Entharion. When + Foo was beheaded by someone he called an "eastern fop" from + Borphee, the glorious age of Pheebor ended, and Borphee rose to + the prominence it now enjoys. + + 5. [OED] A 13th-16th century usage for the devil or any other enemy. + The earliest citation it gives is from the year 1366, Chaucer A B + C (84): "Lat not our alder foo [devil] make his bobance [boast]". + Chaucer's "Foo" is probably related to modern English "foe". + + 6. Rare species of dog. + + A spitz-type dog discovered to exist after having long been + considered extinct, the Chinese Foo Dog, or Sacred Dog of + Sinkiang, may have originated through a crossing of Northern + European hunting dogs and the ancient Chow Chow from Mongolia or + be the missing link between the Chinese Wolf and the Chow Chow. + It probably derives its name from foochow, of the kind or style + + + + +Eastlake, et al. Informational [Page 4] + +RFC 3092 Etymology of "Foo" 1 April 2001 + + + prevalent in Foochow, of or from the city of Foochow (now Minhow) + in southeast China. [DOG] + + foobar n. + + [JARGON] A widely used metasyntactic variable; see foo for + etymology. Probably originally propagated through DECsystem + manuals by Digital Equipment Corporation (DEC) in 1960s and early + 1970s; confirmed sightings there go back to 1972. Hackers do not + generally use this to mean FUBAR in either the slang or jargon + sense. It has been plausibly suggested that "foobar" spread among + early computer engineers partly because of FUBAR and partly + because "foo bar" parses in electronics techspeak as an inverted + foo signal. + + foo-fighter n. + + World War II term for Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs) noted by + both German and British military. See [FF] and entry above for + "foo". + +3. Acronyms + + The following information is derived primarily from the compilations + at University Cork College <http://www.ucc.ie/acronyms> and Acronym + Finder <http://www.AcronymFinder.com> generally filtered for computer + usage. + + .bar: + + Generic file extension which is not meant to imply anything about + the file type. + + BAR: + + Base Address Register + + Buffer Address Register + + FOO: + + Forward Observation Observer. + + FOO Of Oberlin. An organization whose name is a recursive + acronym. Motto: The FOO, the Proud, the FOO. See + <http://cs.oberlin.edu/students/jmankoff/FOO/home.html>. + + File Open for Output. An NFILE error code [RFC1037]. + + + +Eastlake, et al. Informational [Page 5] + +RFC 3092 Etymology of "Foo" 1 April 2001 + + + FOOBAR: + + FTP Operation Over Big Address Records [RFC1639]. (Particularly + appropriate given that the first RFC to use "foo", [RFC269], was + also about file transfer.) + + FUBAR: + + Failed UniBus Address Register - in a VAX, from Digital Equipment + Corporation Engineering. + + Fucked Up Beyond All Recognition/Repair - From US Military in + World War II. Sometimes sanitized to "Fouled Up ...". + + FUBARD - Past tense of FUBAR. + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +Eastlake, et al. Informational [Page 6] + +RFC 3092 Etymology of "Foo" 1 April 2001 + + +Appendix + + Below is a table of RFC occurrences of these words as metasyntactic + variables. (This excludes other uses that are reasonably clear like + "vertical bar" or "bar BoF".) Many of these uses are for example + domain names. That usage may decrease with the specification in [RFC + 2606] of a Best Current Practice for example domain names. + + +------+-----+-----+---------+-------+-----+ + | RFC# | bar | foo | foo.bar | fubar | # | + | | | | foobar | | | + +------+-----+-----+---------+-------+-----+ + | 269 | X | X | | | 1 | + | 441 | X | X | | | 2 | + | 614 | | X | | | 3 | + | 686 | | X | | | 4 | + | 691 | | X | | | 5 | + | 733 | X | X | | | 6 | + | 742 | | X | | | 7 | + | 743 | X | X | | | 8 | + | 756 | | X | | | 9 | + | 765 | X | X | | | 10 | + | 772 | X | X | | X | 11 | + | 775 | | | X | | 12 | + | 780 | X | X | | X | 13 | + | 788 | X | X | | | 14 | + | 810 | X | X | X | | 15 | + | 819 | | X | | | 16 | + | 821 | X | X | | | 17 | + | 822 | X | X | | | 18 | + | 882 | X | X | | | 19 | + | 883 | | X | | | 20 | + | 897 | X | X | | | 21 | + | 913 | | X | | | 22 | + | 921 | X | X | | | 23 | + | 934 | | X | | | 24 | + | 952 | X | X | X | | 25 | + | 959 | | | X | | 26 | + | 976 | | | X | | 27 | + | 977 | | X | X | | 28 | + | 987 | | | X | | 29 | + | 1013 | | X | | | 30 | + | 1033 | X | X | | | 31 | + | 1035 | | X | | | 32 | + | 1037 | | X | | | 33 | + | 1056 | X | X | X | | 34 | + | 1068 | | X | | | 35 | + | 1137 | | | X | | 36 | + + + +Eastlake, et al. Informational [Page 7] + +RFC 3092 Etymology of "Foo" 1 April 2001 + + + | 1138 | | X | X | | 37 | + | 1148 | | X | X | | 38 | + | 1173 | | | X | | 39 | + | 1176 | | | X | | 40 | + | 1186 | | X | | | 41 | + | 1194 | | X | | | 42 | + | 1196 | | X | | | 43 | + | 1203 | | X | X | | 44 | + | 1288 | | X | | | 45 | + | 1291 | | X | | | 46 | + | 1309 | | X | | | 47 | + | 1327 | | X | X | | 48 | + | 1341 | X | X | X | | 49 | + | 1343 | | X | X | | 50 | + | 1344 | | X | | | 51 | + | 1348 | | | X | | 52 | + | 1386 | | X | | | 53 | + | 1408 | | X | | | 54 | + | 1411 | | X | | | 55 | + | 1412 | | X | | | 56 | + | 1459 | X | X | X | X | 57 | + | 1480 | | X | | | 58 | + | 1505 | | X | | | 59 | + | 1519 | | X | | | 60 | + | 1521 | X | X | | | 61 | + | 1523 | | X | | | 62 | + | 1524 | | X | X | | 63 | + | 1526 | X | X | | | 64 | + | 1535 | X | X | X | | 65 | + | 1536 | X | | X | | 66 | + | 1537 | | X | X | | 67 | + | 1563 | | X | | | 68 | + | 1564 | | | X | | 69 | + | 1572 | | X | | | 70 | + | 1573 | | X | | | 71 | + | 1622 | | X | | | 72 | + | 1635 | | | X | | 73 | + | 1636 | | X | X | | 74 | + | 1642 | | X | | | 75 | + | 1645 | | | X | | 76 | + | 1649 | | X | | | 77 | + | 1664 | | | X | | 78 | + | 1681 | | | X | | 79 | + | 1697 | | X | | | 80 | + | 1716 | | X | | | 81 | + | 1718 | | X | | | 82 | + | 1730 | X | X | X | | 83 | + | 1734 | | | X | | 84 | + + + +Eastlake, et al. Informational [Page 8] + +RFC 3092 Etymology of "Foo" 1 April 2001 + + + | 1738 | | X | | | 85 | + | 1783 | | | X | | 86 | + | 1784 | | | X | | 87 | + | 1786 | X | X | | | 88 | + | 1813 | X | X | | | 89 | + | 1835 | | X | X | | 90 | + | 1856 | | | X | | 91 | + | 1861 | | | X | | 92 | + | 1866 | | X | | | 93 | + | 1894 | | | X | | 94 | + | 1896 | | X | | | 95 | + | 1898 | | X | | | 96 | + | 1913 | | X | X | | 97 | + | 1945 | X | X | | | 98 | + | 1985 | | X | X | | 99 | + | 2015 | X | X | | | 100 | + | 2017 | | X | | | 101 | + | 2033 | X | X | | | 102 | + | 2045 | | | X | | 103 | + | 2046 | X | X | | | 104 | + | 2049 | X | X | | | 105 | + | 2055 | | X | | | 106 | + | 2060 | X | X | X | | 107 | + | 2065 | | X | | | 108 | + | 2068 | | | X | | 109 | + | 2071 | | X | | | 110 | + | 2088 | | | X | | 111 | + | 2109 | | X | | | 112 | + | 2110 | | X | X | | 113 | + | 2111 | X | X | X | | 114 | + | 2141 | | X | | | 115 | + | 2150 | | X | | | 116 | + | 2152 | | X | | | 117 | + | 2156 | | X | X | | 118 | + | 2163 | | | X | | 119 | + | 2167 | | | X | | 120 | + | 2168 | | | X | | 121 | + | 2169 | | | X | | 122 | + | 2180 | X | X | | | 123 | + | 2193 | X | X | | | 124 | + | 2224 | | X | | | 125 | + | 2227 | X | X | | | 126 | + | 2233 | | X | | | 127 | + | 2234 | X | X | X | | 128 | + | 2243 | | X | | | 129 | + | 2255 | | X | X | | 130 | + | 2280 | X | X | | | 131 | + | 2295 | | X | | | 132 | + + + +Eastlake, et al. Informational [Page 9] + +RFC 3092 Etymology of "Foo" 1 April 2001 + + + | 2302 | | X | | | 133 | + | 2311 | X | | | | 134 | + | 2326 | X | X | X | | 135 | + | 2342 | | X | | | 136 | + | 2348 | | | X | | 137 | + | 2349 | | | X | | 138 | + | 2359 | | | X | | 139 | + | 2369 | X | X | X | | 140 | + | 2378 | | X | | | 141 | + | 2384 | | | X | | 142 | + | 2392 | X | X | X | | 143 | + | 2396 | | | X | | 144 | + | 2401 | | | X | | 145 | + | 2407 | | | X | | 146 | + | 2421 | | X | | | 147 | + | 2425 | | | X | | 148 | + | 2434 | | X | | | 149 | + | 2446 | | X | X | | 150 | + | 2447 | X | X | | | 151 | + | 2458 | | X | X | | 152 | + | 2459 | | | X | | 153 | + | 2476 | | X | | | 154 | + | 2483 | X | X | | | 155 | + | 2486 | | X | | | 156 | + | 2505 | X | X | | | 157 | + | 2518 | X | X | X | | 158 | + | 2535 | | X | | | 159 | + | 2538 | | X | | | 160 | + | 2543 | X | X | X | | 161 | + | 2554 | | | X | | 162 | + | 2557 | | X | X | | 163 | + | 2565 | | X | X | | 164 | + | 2569 | X | X | | | 165 | + | 2593 | X | X | | | 166 | + | 2595 | | X | | | 167 | + | 2608 | | X | | | 168 | + | 2609 | | X | | | 169 | + | 2616 | X | X | X | | 170 | + | 2622 | X | X | | | 171 | + | 2626 | | X | | | 172 | + | 2633 | X | | | | 173 | + | 2640 | | X | X | | 174 | + | 2645 | | | X | | 175 | + | 2650 | X | | | | 176 | + | 2659 | | | X | | 177 | + | 2673 | | X | X | | 178 | + | 2693 | | X | | | 179 | + | 2704 | X | X | | | 180 | + + + +Eastlake, et al. Informational [Page 10] + +RFC 3092 Etymology of "Foo" 1 April 2001 + + + | 2705 | X | X | | | 181 | + | 2717 | | X | X | | 182 | + | 2725 | X | X | | | 183 | + | 2731 | X | X | X | | 184 | + | 2732 | | X | | | 185 | + | 2782 | | X | X | | 186 | + | 2803 | | X | | | 187 | + | 2806 | | X | | | 188 | + | 2812 | X | X | X | X | 189 | + | 2818 | X | X | | | 190 | + | 2828 | | X | X | | 191 | + | 2830 | X | | | | 192 | + | 2831 | X | X | X | | 193 | + | 2839 | | X | | | 194 | + | 2846 | X | X | | | 195 | + | 2853 | | X | | | 196 | + | 2863 | | X | | | 197 | + | 2910 | | X | X | | 198 | + | 2912 | | X | X | | 199 | + | 2915 | | X | | | 200 | + | 2926 | | | X | | 201 | + | 2942 | | X | | | 202 | + | 2965 | | X | | | 203 | + | 2967 | X | X | X | | 204 | + | 2970 | | X | | | 205 | + | 2993 | X | X | | | 206 | + | 3010 | X | X | | | 207 | + | 3023 | | X | | | 208 | + | 3028 | | X | | | 209 | + | 3075 | X | X | | | 210 | + | 3080 | | X | | | 211 | + | 3092 | X | X | X | X | 212 | + +------+-----+-----+---------+-------+-----+ + | RFC# | bar | foo | foo.bar | fubar | # | + | | | | foobar | | | + +------+-----+-----+---------+-------+-----+ + +Security Considerations + + Security issues are not discussed in this memo. + + + + + + + + + + + +Eastlake, et al. Informational [Page 11] + +RFC 3092 Etymology of "Foo" 1 April 2001 + + +References + + [BFF] "Best of Foo Fighters: Signature Licks", Troy Stetina, Foo + Fighters, October 2000, Hal Leonard Publishing Corporation, + ISBN 063401470. + + [DOG] <http://www.rarebreed.com/breeds/foo/foo.html>. + + + [EAC] "Encyclopedia of American Comics", Ron Goulart, 1990, Facts + on File. + + [EF] "Encyclopedia Frobozzica", + <http://www.everything2.com/index.pl?node=Prince%20Foo> + + [FF] Foo Fighters - "The Rainbow Conspiracy", Brad Steiger, + Sherry Hansen Steiger, December 1998, Kensington Publishing + Corp., ISBN 1575663635. - Computer UFO Network + <http://www.cufon.org> particularly + <http://www.cufon.org/cufon/foo.htm>. + + [FOLDOC] "Free On-Line Dictionary Of Computing", + <http://www.foldoc.org>. + + [JARGON] The Jargon File. See <http://www.jargon.org>. Last + printed as "The New Hacker's Dictionary", Eric S. Raymond, + 3rd Edition, MIT Press, ISBN 0-262-68092-0, 1996. + + [OED] "The Oxford English Dictionary", J. A. Simpson, 1989, + Oxford University Press, ISBN 0198611862. + + [PERS] Personal communications. + + [RFC269] Brodie, H., "Some Experience with File Transfer", RFC 269, + December 1971. + + [RFC1037] Greenberg, B. and S. Keene, "NFILE - A File Access + Protocol", RFC 1037, December 1987. + + [RFC1639] Piscitello, D., "FTP Operation Over Big Address Records + (FOOBAR)", RFC 1639, June 1994. + + [RFC2606] Eastlake, D. and A. Panitz, "Reserved Top Level DNS Names", + BCP 32, RFC 2606, June 1999. + + + + + + + +Eastlake, et al. Informational [Page 12] + +RFC 3092 Etymology of "Foo" 1 April 2001 + + + [TMRC] The Tech Model Railroad Club (The Model Railroad Club of + the Massachusetts Institute of Technology) Dictionary, + <http://tmrc-www.mit.edu/dictionary.html>. + + [WBCC] "Warner Brothers Cartoon Companion", + <http://members.aol.com/EOCostello/>. + + [WORDS] "Words", Paul Dickson, ISBN 0-440-52260-7, Dell, 1982. + +Authors' Addresses + + The authors of this document are: + + Donald E. Eastlake 3rd + Motorola + 155 Beaver Street + Milford, MA 01757 USA + + Phone: +1 508-261-5434 (w) + +1 508-634-2066 (h) + Fax: +1 508-261-4777 (w) + EMail: Donald.Eastlake@motorola.com + + + Carl-Uno Manros + Xerox Corporation + 701 Aviation Blvd. + El Segundo, CA 90245 USA + + Phone: +1 310-333-8273 + Fax: +1 310-333-5514 + EMail: manros@cp10.es.xerox.com + + + Eric S. Raymond + Open Source Initiative + 6 Karen Drive + Malvern, PA 19355 + + Phone: +1 610-296-5718 + EMail: esr@thyrsus.com + + + + + + + + + + +Eastlake, et al. Informational [Page 13] + +RFC 3092 Etymology of "Foo" 1 April 2001 + + +Full Copyright Statement + + Copyright (C) The Internet Society (2001). All Rights Reserved. + + This document and translations of it may be copied and furnished to + others, and derivative works that comment on or otherwise explain it + or assist in its implementation may be prepared, copied, published + and distributed, in whole or in part, without restriction of any + kind, provided that the above copyright notice and this paragraph are + included on all such copies and derivative works. However, this + document itself may not be modified in any way, such as by removing + the copyright notice or references to the Internet Society or other + Internet organizations, except as needed for the purpose of + developing Internet standards in which case the procedures for + copyrights defined in the Internet Standards process must be + followed, or as required to translate it into languages other than + English. + + The limited permissions granted above are perpetual and will not be + revoked by the Internet Society or its successors or assigns. + + This document and the information contained herein is provided on an + "AS IS" basis and THE INTERNET SOCIETY AND THE INTERNET ENGINEERING + TASK FORCE DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING + BUT NOT LIMITED TO ANY WARRANTY THAT THE USE OF THE INFORMATION + HEREIN WILL NOT INFRINGE ANY RIGHTS OR ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF + MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. + +Acknowledgement + + Funding for the RFC Editor function is currently provided by the + Internet Society. + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +Eastlake, et al. Informational [Page 14] + |