path: root/doc/rfc/rfc6988.txt

Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF)                   J. Quittek, Ed.
Request for Comments: 6988                               NEC Europe Ltd.
Category: Informational                                  M. Chandramouli
ISSN: 2070-1721                                      Cisco Systems, Inc.
                                                               R. Winter
                                                                T. Dietz
                                                         NEC Europe Ltd.
                                                               B. Claise
                                                     Cisco Systems, Inc.
                                                          September 2013


                   Requirements for Energy Management

Abstract

   This document defines requirements for standards specifications for
   Energy Management.  The requirements defined in this document are
   concerned with monitoring functions as well as control functions.
   Monitoring functions include identifying energy-managed devices and
   their components, as well as monitoring their Power States, Power
   Inlets, Power Outlets, actual power, Power Attributes, received
   energy, provided energy, and contained batteries.  Control functions
   include such functions as controlling power supply and Power State of
   energy-managed devices and their components.

   This document does not specify the features that must be implemented
   by compliant implementations but rather lists features that must be
   supported by standards for Energy Management.

Status of This Memo

   This document is not an Internet Standards Track specification; it is
   published for informational purposes.

   This document is a product of the Internet Engineering Task Force
   (IETF).  It represents the consensus of the IETF community.  It has
   received public review and has been approved for publication by the
   Internet Engineering Steering Group (IESG).  Not all documents
   approved by the IESG are a candidate for any level of Internet
   Standard; see Section 2 of RFC 5741.

   Information about the current status of this document, any errata,
   and how to provide feedback on it may be obtained at
   http://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc6988.






Quittek, et al.               Informational                     [Page 1]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


Copyright Notice

   Copyright (c) 2013 IETF Trust and the persons identified as the
   document authors.  All rights reserved.

   This document is subject to BCP 78 and the IETF Trust's Legal
   Provisions Relating to IETF Documents
   (http://trustee.ietf.org/license-info) in effect on the date of
   publication of this document.  Please review these documents
   carefully, as they describe your rights and restrictions with respect
   to this document.  Code Components extracted from this document must
   include Simplified BSD License text as described in Section 4.e of
   the Trust Legal Provisions and are provided without warranty as
   described in the Simplified BSD License.

Table of Contents

   1. Introduction ....................................................3
      1.1. Conventional Requirements for Energy Management ............3
      1.2. Specific Requirements for Energy Management ................4
   2. Terminology .....................................................5
   3. General Considerations Related to Energy Management .............6
      3.1. Power States ...............................................7
      3.2. Saving Energy versus Maintaining Service Level .............7
      3.3. Local versus Network-Wide Energy Management ................7
      3.4. Energy Monitoring versus Energy Saving .....................8
      3.5. Overview of Energy Management Requirements .................8
   4. Identification of Entities ......................................9
   5. Information on Entities ........................................10
      5.1. General Information on Entities ...........................10
      5.2. Power Interfaces ..........................................11
      5.3. Power .....................................................13
      5.4. Power State ...............................................15
      5.5. Energy ....................................................17
      5.6. Battery State .............................................18
      5.7. Time Series of Measured Values ............................19
   6. Control of Entities ............................................21
   7. Reporting on Other Entities ....................................21
   8. Controlling Other Entities .....................................22
      8.1. Controlling Power States of Other Entities ................22
      8.2. Controlling Power Supply ..................................23
   9. Security Considerations ........................................23
   10. Acknowledgments ...............................................25
   11. References ....................................................25
      11.1. Normative References .....................................25
      11.2. Informative References ...................................26





Quittek, et al.               Informational                     [Page 2]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


1.  Introduction

   With rising energy costs and an increasing awareness of the
   ecological impact of running information technology equipment, Energy
   Management (EMAN) functions and interfaces are becoming an additional
   basic requirement for network management systems and devices
   connected to a network.

   This document defines requirements for standards specifications for
   Energy Management, both monitoring functions and control functions.
   Energy Management functions focus mainly on devices and their
   components that receive and provide electrical energy.  Devices such
   as hosts, routers, and middleboxes may have an IP address or may be
   connected indirectly to the Internet via a proxy with an IP address
   providing a management interface for the device, for example, devices
   in a building infrastructure using non-IP protocols and a gateway to
   the Internet.

   These requirements are concerned with the standards specification
   process and not the implementation of specified standards.  All
   requirements in this document must be reflected by standards
   specifications to be developed.  However, which of the features
   specified by these standards will be mandatory, recommended, or
   optional for compliant implementations is to be defined by Standards
   Track document(s) and not in this document.

   Section 3 elaborates on a set of general needs for Energy Management.
   Requirements for an Energy Management standard are specified in
   Sections 4 through 8.

   Sections 4 through 6 contain conventional requirements specifying
   information on entities and control functions.

   Sections 7 and 8 contain requirements specific to Energy Management.
   Due to the nature of power supply, some monitoring and control
   functions are not conducted by interacting with the entity of
   interest but rather with other entities, for example, entities
   upstream in a power distribution tree.

1.1.  Conventional Requirements for Energy Management

   The specification of requirements for an Energy Management standard
   starts with Section 4, which addresses the identification of entities
   and the granularity of reporting of energy-related information.  A
   standard must support the unique identification of entities,
   reporting per entire device, and reporting energy-related information
   on individual components of a device or attached devices.




Quittek, et al.               Informational                     [Page 3]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


   Section 5 specifies requirements related to the monitoring of
   entities.  This includes general (type, context) information and
   specific information on Power States, Power Inlets, Power Outlets,
   power, energy, and batteries.  The control of Power State and power
   supply by entities is covered by requirements specified in Section 6.

1.2.  Specific Requirements for Energy Management

   While the conventional requirements summarized above seem to be all
   that would be needed for Energy Management, there are significant
   differences between Energy Management and most well-known network
   management functions.  The most significant difference is the need
   for some devices to report on other entities.  There are three major
   reasons for this.

   o  For monitoring a particular entity, it is not always sufficient to
      communicate only with that entity.  When the entity has no
      instrumentation for determining power, it might still be possible
      to obtain power values for the entity via communication with other
      entities in its power distribution tree.  A simple example of this
      would be the retrieval of power values from a power meter at the
      power line into the entity.  A Power Distribution Unit (PDU) and a
      Power over Ethernet (PoE) switch are common examples.  Both supply
      power to other entities at sockets or ports, respectively, and are
      often instrumented to measure power per socket or port.

   o  Similar considerations apply to controlling the power supply of an
      entity that often needs direct or indirect communications with
      another entity upstream in the power distribution tree.  Again, a
      PDU and a PoE switch are common examples, if they have the
      capability to switch power on or off at their sockets or ports,
      respectively.

   o  Energy Management often extends beyond entities with IP network
      interfaces to non-IP building systems accessed via a gateway
      (sometimes called an Energy Management System or controller).
      Requirements in this document do not cover the details of these
      networks and energy devices but specify means for opening IP
      network management towards them.

   These specific issues of Energy Management, as well as other issues,
   are covered by requirements specified in Sections 7 and 8.

   The requirements in these sections need a new Energy Management
   framework that deals with the specific nature of Energy Management.
   The actual standards documents, such as MIB module specifications,
   address conformance by specifying which features must, should, or may
   be implemented by compliant implementations.



Quittek, et al.               Informational                     [Page 4]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


2.  Terminology

   The terms specified in the terminology section are capitalized
   throughout the document; the exceptions are the well-known terms
   "energy" and "power".  These terms are generic and are used in
   generated terms such as "energy-saving", "low-power", etc.

   Energy

      Energy is the capacity of a system to do work.  As used by
      electric utilities, it is generally a reference to electrical
      energy and is measured in kilowatt-hours (kWh) [IEEE-100].

   Power

      Power is the time rate at which energy is emitted, transferred, or
      received; power is usually expressed in watts (or in joules per
      second) [IEEE-100].  (The term "power" does not refer to the
      concept of demand, which is an averaged power value.)

   Power Attributes

      Power Attributes are measurements of electric current, voltage,
      phase, and frequencies at a given point in an electrical power
      system (adapted from [IEC.60050]).

      NOTE: Power Attributes are not intended to be "judgmental" with
      respect to a reference or technical value and are independent of
      any usage context.

   Energy Management

      Energy Management is a set of functions for measuring, modeling,
      planning, and optimizing networks to ensure that the network
      elements and attached devices use energy efficiently and in a
      manner appropriate to the nature of the application and the cost
      constraints of the organization [ITU-M.3400].

   Energy Management System

      An Energy Management System is a combination of hardware and
      software used to administer a network with the primary purpose
      being Energy Management.








Quittek, et al.               Informational                     [Page 5]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


   Energy Monitoring

      Energy Monitoring is a part of Energy Management that deals with
      collecting or reading information from network elements and
      attached devices and their components to aid in Energy Management.

   Energy Control

      Energy Control is a part of Energy Management that deals with
      controlling energy supply and Power State of network elements, as
      well as attached devices and their components.

   Power Interface

      A Power Interface is an interface at which a device is connected
      to a power transmission medium, at which it can in turn receive
      power, provide power, or both.

   Power Inlet

      A Power Inlet is a Power Interface at which a device can receive
      power from other devices.

   Power Outlet

      A Power Outlet is a Power Interface at which a device can provide
      power to other devices.

   Power State

      A Power State is a condition or mode of a device that broadly
      characterizes its capabilities, power consumption, and
      responsiveness to input [IEEE-1621].

3.  General Considerations Related to Energy Management

   The basic objective of Energy Management is to operate sets of
   devices using minimal energy, while maintaining a certain level of
   service.  [EMAN-STATEMENT] presents the applicability of the EMAN
   framework to a variety of scenarios and also lists use cases and
   target devices.










Quittek, et al.               Informational                     [Page 6]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


3.1.  Power States

   Entities can be set to an operational state that results in the
   lowest power level that still meets the service-level performance
   objectives.  In principle, there are three basic types of Power
   States for an entity or for a whole system:

   o  full Power State

   o  sleep state (not functional but immediately available)

   o  off state (may require significant time to become operational)

   In specific devices, the number of Power States and their properties
   vary considerably.  Simple entities may only have the extreme states:
   full Power State and off state.  Many devices have three basic Power
   States: on, off, and sleep.  However, more finely grained Power
   States can be implemented.  Examples are various operational low
   Power States in which a device requires less energy than in the full
   power "on" state, but -- compared to the sleep state -- is still
   operational with reduced performance or functionality.

3.2.  Saving Energy versus Maintaining Service Level

   One of the objectives of Energy Management is to reduce energy
   consumption.  While this objective is clear, attaining that goal is
   often difficult.  In many cases, there is no way to reduce power
   without the consequence of a potential service (performance or
   capacity) degradation.  In this case, a trade-off needs to be made
   between service-level objectives and energy minimization.  In other
   cases, a reduction of power can easily be achieved while still
   maintaining sufficient service-level performance, for example, by
   switching entities to lower Power States when higher performance is
   not needed.

3.3.  Local versus Network-Wide Energy Management

   Many energy-saving functions are executed locally by an entity; it
   monitors its usage and dynamically adapts its power according to the
   required performance.  It may, for example, switch to a sleep state
   when it is not in use, or outside of scheduled business hours.  An
   Energy Management System may observe an entity's Power State and
   configure its power-saving policies.

   Energy savings can also be achieved with policies implemented by a
   network management system that controls Power States of managed
   entities.  Information about the power received and provided by




Quittek, et al.               Informational                     [Page 7]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


   entities in different Power States may be required in order to set
   such policies.  Often, this information is best acquired through
   monitoring.

   Network-wide and local Energy Management methods both have advantages
   and disadvantages, and it is often desirable to combine them.
   Central management is often favorable for setting Power States of a
   large number of entities at the same time, for example, at the
   beginning and end of business hours in a building.  Local management
   is often preferable for power-saving measures based on local
   observations, such as the high or low functional load of an entity.

3.4.  Energy Monitoring versus Energy Saving

   Monitoring energy, power, and Power States alone does not reduce the
   energy needed to run an entity.  In fact, it may even increase it
   slightly due to monitoring instrumentation that needs energy.
   Reporting measured quantities over the network may also increase
   energy use, though the acquired information may be an essential input
   to control loops that save energy.

   Monitoring energy and Power States can also be required for other
   purposes, including:

   o  investigating energy-saving potential

   o  evaluating the effectiveness of energy-saving policies and
      measures

   o  deriving, implementing, and testing power management strategies

   o  accounting for the total power received and provided by an entity,
      a network, or a service

   o  predicting an entity's reliability based on power usage

   o  choosing the time of the next maintenance cycle for an entity

3.5.  Overview of Energy Management Requirements

   The following basic management functions are required:

   o  monitoring Power States

   o  monitoring power (energy conversion rate)

   o  monitoring (accumulated) received and provided energy




Quittek, et al.               Informational                     [Page 8]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


   o  monitoring Power Attributes

   o  setting Power States

   Power control is complementary to other energy-saving measures, such
   as low-power electronics, energy-saving protocols, energy-efficient
   device design (for example, low-power modes for components), and
   energy-efficient network architectures.  Measurement of received and
   provided energy can provide useful data for developing these
   technologies.

4.  Identification of Entities

   Entities must be capable of being uniquely identified within the
   context of the management system.  This includes entities that are
   components of managed devices as well as entire devices.

   Entities that report on or control other entities must identify the
   entities they report on or control: see Section 7 or Section 8,
   respectively, for the detailed requirements.

   An entity may be an entire device or a component of it.  Examples of
   components of interest are a hard drive, a battery, or a line card.
   The ability to control individual components to save energy may be
   required.  For example, server blades can be switched off when the
   overall load is low, or line cards at switches may be powered down at
   night.

   Identifiers for devices and components are already defined in
   standard MIB modules, such as the Link Layer Discovery Protocol
   (LLDP) MIB module [IEEE-802.1AB] and the Link Layer Discovery
   Protocol -- Media Endpoint Discovery (LLDP-MED) MIB module
   [ANSI-TIA-1057] for devices, and the Entity MIB module [RFC6933] and
   the power Ethernet MIB [RFC3621] for components of devices.  Energy
   Management needs a means to link energy-related information to such
   identifiers.

   Instrumentation for measuring the received and provided energy of a
   device is typically more expensive than instrumentation for
   retrieving its Power State.  Many devices may provide Power State
   information for all individual components separately, while reporting
   the received and provided energy only for the entire device.

4.1.  Identifying Entities

   The standard must provide means for uniquely identifying entities.
   Uniqueness must be preserved such that collisions of identities are
   avoided at potential receivers of monitored information.



Quittek, et al.               Informational                     [Page 9]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


4.2.  Persistence of Identifiers

   The standard must provide means for indicating whether identifiers of
   entities are persistent across a restart of the entity.

4.3.  Change of Identifiers

   The standard must provide means to indicate any change of entity
   identifiers.

4.4.  Using Entity Identifiers of Existing MIB Modules

   The standard must provide means for reusing entity identifiers from
   existing standards, including at least the following:

   o  the entPhysicalIndex in the Entity MIB module [RFC6933]

   o  the LldpPortNumber in the LLDP MIB module [IEEE-802.1AB] and in
      the LLDP-MED MIB module [ANSI-TIA-1057]

   o  the pethPsePortIndex and the pethPsePortGroupIndex in the Power
      Ethernet MIB [RFC3621]

   Generic means for reusing other entity identifiers must be provided.

5.  Information on Entities

   This section describes information on entities for which the standard
   must provide means for retrieving and reporting.

   Required information can be structured into seven groups.
   Section 5.1 specifies requirements for general information on
   entities, such as type of entity or context information.
   Requirements for information on Power Inlets and Power Outlets of
   entities are specified in Section 5.2.  The monitoring of power and
   energy is covered by Sections 5.3 and 5.5, respectively.  Section 5.4
   covers requirements related to entities' Power States.  Section 5.6
   specifies requirements for monitoring batteries.  Finally, the
   reporting of time series of values is covered by Section 5.7.

5.1.  General Information on Entities

   For Energy Management, understanding the role and context of an
   entity may be required.  An Energy Management System may aggregate
   values of received and provided energy according to a defined
   grouping of entities.  When controlling and setting Power States, it
   may be helpful to understand the grouping of the entity and role of




Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 10]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


   an entity in a network.  For example, it may be important to exclude
   some mission-critical network devices from being switched to lower
   power or even from being switched off.

5.1.1.  Type of Entity

   The standard must provide means to configure, retrieve, and report a
   textual name or a description of an entity.

5.1.2.  Context of an Entity

   The standard must provide means for retrieving and reporting context
   information on entities, for example, tags associated with an entity
   that indicate the entity's role.

5.1.3.  Significance of Entities

   The standard must provide means for retrieving and reporting the
   significance of entities within its context, for example, how
   important the entity is.

5.1.4.  Power Priority

   The standard must provide means for retrieving and reporting power
   priorities of entities.  Power priorities indicate an order in which
   Power States of entities are changed, for example, to lower Power
   States for saving power.

5.1.5.  Grouping of Entities

   The standard must provide means for grouping entities.  This can be
   achieved in multiple ways, for example, by providing means to tag
   entities, assign them to domains, or assign device types to them.

5.2.  Power Interfaces

   A Power Interface is an interface at which a device is connected to a
   power transmission medium, at which it can in turn receive power,
   provide power, or both.

   A Power Interface is either an inlet or an outlet.  Some Power
   Interfaces change over time from being an inlet to being an outlet
   and vice versa.  However, most Power Interfaces never change.

   Devices have Power Inlets at which they are supplied with electric
   power.  Most devices have a single Power Inlet, while some have
   multiple inlets.  Different Power Inlets on a device are often
   connected to separate power distribution trees.  For Energy



Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 11]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


   Monitoring, it is useful to retrieve information on the number of
   inlets of a device, the availability of power at inlets, and which
   inlets are actually in use.

   Devices can have one or more Power Outlets for supplying other
   devices with electric power.

   For identifying and potentially controlling the source of power
   received at an inlet, identifying the Power Outlet of another device
   at which the received power is provided may be required.
   Analogously, for each outlet, it is of interest to identify the Power
   Inlets that receive the power provided at a certain outlet.  Such
   information is also required for constructing the wiring topology of
   electrical power distribution to devices.

   Static properties of each Power Interface are required information
   for Energy Management.  Static properties include the kind of
   electric current (AC or DC), the nominal voltage, the nominal AC
   frequency, and the number of AC phases.  Note that the nominal
   voltage is often not a single value but a voltage range, such as, for
   example, (100V-120V), (100V-240V), (100V-120V,220V-240V).

5.2.1.  List of Power Interfaces

   The standard must provide means for monitoring the list of Power
   Interfaces of a device.

5.2.2.  Operational Mode of Power Interfaces

   The standard must provide means for monitoring the operational mode
   of a Power Interface, which is either "Power Inlet" or "Power
   Outlet".

5.2.3.  Corresponding Power Outlet

   The standard must provide means for identifying the Power Outlet that
   provides the power received at a Power Inlet.

5.2.4.  Corresponding Power Inlets

   The standard must provide means for identifying the list of Power
   Inlets that receive the power provided at a Power Outlet.









Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 12]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


5.2.5.  Availability of Power

   If the Power States allow it, the standard must provide means for
   monitoring the availability of power at each Power Interface.  This
   includes indicating whether a power supply at a Power Interface is
   switched on or off.

5.2.6.  Use of Power

   The standard must provide means for monitoring each Power Interface
   if it is actually in use.  For inlets, this means that the device
   actually receives power at the inlet.  For outlets, this means that
   power is actually provided from the outlet to one or more devices.

5.2.7.  Type of Current

   The standard must provide means for reporting the type of current (AC
   or DC) for each Power Interface as well as for a device.

5.2.8.  Nominal Voltage Range

   The standard must provide means for reporting the nominal voltage
   range for each Power Interface.

5.2.9.  Nominal AC Frequency

   The standard must provide means for reporting the nominal AC
   frequency for each Power Interface.

5.2.10.  Number of AC Phases

   The standard must provide means for reporting the number of AC phases
   for each Power Interface.

5.3.  Power

   Power is measured as an instantaneous value or as the average over a
   time interval.

   Obtaining highly accurate values for power and energy may be costly
   if dedicated metering hardware is required.  Entities without the
   ability to measure with high accuracy their power, received energy,
   and provided energy may just report estimated values, for example,
   based on load monitoring, Power State, or even just the entity type.

   Depending on how power and energy values are obtained, the confidence
   in a reported value and its accuracy will vary.  Entities reporting
   such values should qualify the confidence in the reported values and



Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 13]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


   quantify the accuracy of measurements.  For reporting accuracy, the
   accuracy classes specified in IEC 62053-21 [IEC.62053-21] and
   IEC 62053-22 [IEC.62053-22] should be considered.

   Further properties of the power supplied to a device are also of
   interest.  For AC power supply in particular, several Power
   Attributes beyond the real power are of potential interest to Energy
   Management Systems.  The set of these properties includes the complex
   Power Attributes (apparent power, reactive power, and phase angle of
   the current or power factor) as well as the actual voltage, the
   actual AC frequency, the Total Harmonic Distortion (THD) of voltage
   and current, and the impedance of an AC phase or of the DC supply.  A
   new standard for monitoring these Power Attributes should be in line
   with already-existing standards, such as [IEC.61850-7-4].

   For some network management tasks, it is desirable to receive
   notifications from entities when their power value exceeds or falls
   below given thresholds.

5.3.1.  Real Power / Power Factor

   The standard must provide means for reporting the real power for each
   Power Interface as well as for an entity.  Reporting power includes
   reporting the direction of power flow.

5.3.2.  Power Measurement Interval

   The standard must provide means for reporting the corresponding time
   or time interval for which a power value is reported.  The power
   value can be measured at the corresponding time or averaged over the
   corresponding time interval.

5.3.3.  Power Measurement Method

   The standard must provide means to indicate the method used to obtain
   these values.  Based on how the measurement was conducted, it is
   possible to associate a certain degree of confidence with the
   reported power value.  For example, there are methods of measurement
   such as direct power measurement, estimation based on performance
   values, or hard-coding average power values for an entity.

5.3.4.  Accuracy of Power and Energy Values

   The standard must provide means for reporting the accuracy of
   reported power and energy values.






Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 14]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


5.3.5.  Actual Voltage and Current

   The standard must provide means for reporting the actual voltage and
   actual current for each Power Interface as well as for a device.  For
   AC power supply, means must be provided for reporting the actual
   voltage and actual current per phase.

5.3.6.  High-Power/Low-Power Notifications

   The standard must provide means for creating notifications if power
   values of an entity rise above or fall below given thresholds.

5.3.7.  Complex Power / Power Factor

   The standard must provide means for reporting the complex power for
   each Power Interface and for each phase at a Power Interface.  In
   addition to the real power, at least two of the following three
   quantities need to be reported: apparent power, reactive power, and
   phase angle.  The phase angle can be substituted by the power factor.

5.3.8.  Actual AC Frequency

   The standard must provide means for reporting the actual AC frequency
   for each Power Interface.

5.3.9.  Total Harmonic Distortion

   The standard must provide means for reporting the Total Harmonic
   Distortion (THD) of voltage and current for each Power Interface.
   For AC power supply, means must be provided for reporting the THD per
   phase.

5.3.10.  Power Supply Impedance

   The standard must provide means for reporting the impedance of a
   power supply for each Power Interface.  For AC power supply, means
   must be provided for reporting the impedance per phase.

5.4.  Power State

   Many entities have a limited number of discrete Power States.

   There is a need to report the actual Power State of an entity and to
   provide the means for retrieving the list of all supported Power
   States.






Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 15]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


   Different standards bodies have already defined sets of Power States
   for some entities, and others are creating new Power State sets.  In
   this context, it is desirable that the standard support many of these
   Power State standards.  In order to support multiple management
   systems that possibly use different Power State sets while
   simultaneously interfacing with a particular entity, the Energy
   Management System must provide means for supporting multiple Power
   State sets used simultaneously at an entity.

   Power States have parameters that describe their properties.  It is
   required to have a standardized means for reporting some key
   properties, such as the typical power of an entity in a certain
   state.

   There is also a need to report statistics on Power States, including
   the time spent as well as the received and provided energy in a Power
   State.

5.4.1.  Actual Power State

   The standard must provide means for reporting the actual Power State
   of an entity.

5.4.2.  List of Supported Power States

   The standard must provide means for retrieving the list of all
   potential Power States of an entity.

5.4.3.  Multiple Power State Sets

   The standard must provide means for supporting multiple Power State
   sets simultaneously at an entity.

5.4.4.  List of Supported Power State Sets

   The standard must provide means for retrieving the list of all Power
   State sets supported by an entity.

5.4.5.  List of Supported Power States within a Set

   The standard must provide means for retrieving the list of all
   potential Power States of an entity for each supported Power State
   set.

5.4.6.  Typical Power Per Power State

   The standard must provide means for retrieving the typical power for
   each supported Power State.



Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 16]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


5.4.7.  Power State Statistics

   The standard must provide means for monitoring statistics per Power
   State, including the total time spent in a Power State, the number of
   times each state was entered, and the last time each state was
   entered.  More Power State statistics are addressed by the
   requirements in Section 5.5.3.

5.4.8.  Power State Changes

   The standard must provide means for generating a notification when
   the actual Power State of an entity changes.

5.5.  Energy

   The monitoring of electrical energy received or provided by an entity
   is a core function of Energy Management.  Since energy is an
   accumulated quantity, it is always reported for a certain interval of
   time.  This can be, for example, the time from the last restart of
   the entity to the reporting time, the time from another past event to
   the reporting time, the last given amount of time before the
   reporting time, or a certain interval specified by two timestamps in
   the past.

   It is useful for entities to record their received and provided
   energy per Power State and report these quantities.

5.5.1.  Energy Measurement

   The standard must provide means for reporting measured values of
   energy and the direction of the energy flow received or provided by
   an entity.  The standard must also provide the means to report the
   energy passing through each Power Interface.

5.5.2.  Time Intervals

   The standard must provide means for reporting the time interval for
   which an energy value is reported.

5.5.3.  Energy Per Power State

   The standard must provide means for reporting the received and
   provided energy for each individual Power State.  This extends the
   requirements on Power State statistics described in Section 5.4.7.







Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 17]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


5.6.  Battery State

   Batteries are special entities that supply power.  The status of
   these batteries is typically controlled by automatic functions that
   act locally on the entity, and manually by users of the entity.
   There is a need to monitor the battery status of these entities by
   network management systems.

   Devices containing batteries can be modeled in two ways.  The entire
   device can be modeled as a single entity on which energy-related
   information is reported, or the battery can be modeled as an
   individual entity for which energy-related information is monitored
   individually according to requirements in Sections 5.1 through 5.5.

   Further information on batteries is of interest for Energy
   Management, such as the current charge of the battery, the number of
   completed charging cycles, the charging state of the battery, its
   temperature, and additional static and dynamic battery properties.
   It is desirable to receive notifications if the charge of a battery
   becomes very low or if a battery needs to be replaced.

5.6.1.  Battery Charge

   The standard must provide means for reporting the current charge of a
   battery, in units of milliampere-hours (mAh).

5.6.2.  Battery Charging State

   The standard must provide means for reporting the charging state
   (charging, discharging, etc.) of a battery.

5.6.3.  Battery Charging Cycles

   The standard must provide means for reporting the number of completed
   charging cycles of a battery.

5.6.4.  Actual Battery Capacity

   The standard must provide means for reporting the actual capacity of
   a battery.

5.6.5.  Actual Battery Temperature

   The standard must provide means for reporting the actual temperature
   of a battery.






Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 18]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


5.6.6.  Static Battery Properties

   The standard must provide means for reporting static properties of a
   battery, including the nominal capacity, the number of cells, the
   nominal voltage, and the battery technology.

5.6.7.  Low Battery Charge Notification

   The standard must provide means for generating a notification when
   the charge of a battery decreases below a given threshold.  Note that
   the threshold may depend on the battery technology.

5.6.8.  Battery Replacement Notification

   The standard must provide means for generating a notification when
   the number of charging cycles of a battery exceeds a given threshold.

5.6.9.  Multiple Batteries

   If the battery technology allows, the standard must provide means for
   meeting requirements in Sections 5.6.1 through 5.6.8 for each
   individual battery contained in a single entity.

5.7.  Time Series of Measured Values

   For some network management tasks, obtaining time series of measured
   values from entities, such as power, energy, battery charge, etc., is
   required.

   In general, time series measurements could be obtained in many
   different ways.  Means should be provided to either push such values
   from the location where they are available to the management system
   or to have them stored locally for a sufficiently long period of time
   such that a management system can retrieve the full time series.

   The following issues are to be considered when designing time series
   measurement and reporting functions:

   1.  Which quantities should be reported?

   2.  Which time interval type should be used (total, delta, sliding
       window)?

   3.  Which measurement method should be used (sampled, continuous)?

   4.  Which reporting model should be used (push or pull)?





Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 19]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


   The most discussed and probably most needed quantity is energy.  But
   a need for others, such as power and battery charge, can be
   identified as well.

   There are three time interval types under discussion for accumulated
   quantities such as energy.  They can be reported as total values,
   accumulated between the last restart of the measurement and a certain
   timestamp.  Alternatively, energy can be reported as delta values
   between two consecutive timestamps.  Another alternative is reporting
   values for sliding windows as specified in [IEC.61850-7-4].

   For non-accumulative quantities, such as power, different measurement
   methods are considered.  Such quantities can be reported using values
   sampled at certain timestamps or, alternatively, by mean values for
   these quantities averaged between two (consecutive) timestamps or
   over a sliding window.

   Finally, time series can be reported using different reporting
   models, particularly push-based or pull-based.  Push-based reporting
   can, for example, be realized by reporting power or energy values
   using the IP Flow Information Export (IPFIX) protocol [RFC7011]
   [RFC7012].  The Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMP) [RFC3411]
   is an example of a protocol that can be used for realizing pull-based
   reporting of time series.

   For reporting time series of measured values, the following
   requirements have been identified.  Further decisions concerning
   issues discussed above need to be made when developing concrete
   Energy Management standards.

5.7.1.  Time Series of Energy Values

   The standard must provide means for reporting time series of energy
   values.  If the comparison of time series between multiple entities
   is required, then time synchronization between those entities must be
   provided (for example, with the Network Time Protocol [RFC5905]).

5.7.2.  Time Series Interval Types

   The standard must provide means for supporting alternative interval
   types.  The requirement in Section 5.5.2 applies to every reported
   time value.

5.7.3.  Time Series Storage Capacity

   The standard should provide means for reporting the number of values
   of a time series that can be stored for later reporting.




Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 20]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


6.  Control of Entities

   Many entities control their Power State locally.  Other entities need
   interfaces for an Energy Management System to control their Power
   State.

   A power supply is typically not self-managed by devices, and control
   of a power supply is typically not conducted as an interaction
   between an Energy Management System and the device itself.  It is
   rather an interaction between the management system and a device
   providing power at its Power Outlets.  Similar to Power State
   control, power supply control may be policy driven.  Note that
   shutting down the power supply abruptly may have severe consequences
   for the device.

6.1.  Controlling Power States

   The standard must provide means for setting Power States of entities.

6.2.  Controlling Power Supply

   The standard must provide means for switching a power supply off or
   turning a power supply on at Power Interfaces providing power to one
   or more devices.

7.  Reporting on Other Entities

   As discussed in Section 5, not all energy-related information may be
   available at the entity in question.  Such information may be
   provided by other entities.  This section covers only the reporting
   of information.  See Section 8 for requirements on controlling other
   entities.

   There are cases where a power supply unit switches power for several
   entities by turning power on or off at a single Power Outlet or where
   a power meter measures the accumulated power of several entities at a
   single power line.  Consequently, it should be possible to report
   that a monitored value does not relate to just a single entity but is
   an accumulated value for a set of entities.  All of the entities
   belonging to that set need to be identified.

7.1.  Reports on Other Entities

   The standard must provide means for an entity to report information
   on another entity.






Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 21]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


7.2.  Identity of Other Entities on Which Information Is Reported

   For entities that report on one or more other entities, the standard
   must provide means for reporting the identity of other entities on
   which information is reported.  Note that, in some situations, a
   manual configuration might be required to populate this information.

7.3.  Reporting Quantities Accumulated over Multiple Entities

   The standard must provide means for reporting the list of all
   entities from which contributions are included in an accumulated
   value.

7.4.  List of All Entities on Which Information Is Reported

   For entities that report on one or more other entities, the standard
   must provide means for reporting the complete list of all those
   entities on which energy-related information can be reported.

7.5.  Content of Reports on Other Entities

   For entities that report on one or more other entities, the standard
   must provide means for indicating what type or types of energy-
   related information can be reported, and for which entities.

8.  Controlling Other Entities

   This section specifies requirements for controlling Power States and
   power supply of entities by communicating with other entities that
   have the means for doing that control.

8.1.  Controlling Power States of Other Entities

   Some entities have control over Power States of other entities.  For
   example, a gateway to a building system may have the means to control
   the Power State of entities in the building that do not have an IP
   interface.  For this scenario and other similar cases, a way to make
   this control accessible to the Energy Management System is needed.

   In addition, it is required that an entity that has its state
   controlled by other entities has the means to report the list of
   these other entities.









Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 22]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


8.1.1.  Control of Power States of Other Entities

   The standard must provide means for an Energy Management System to
   send Power State control commands to an entity that controls the
   Power States of entities other than the entity to which the command
   was sent.

8.1.2.  Identity of Other Power State Controlled Entities

   The standard must provide means for reporting the identities of the
   entities for which the reporting entity has the means to control
   their Power States.  Note that, in some situations, a manual
   configuration might be required to populate this information.

8.1.3.  List of All Power State Controlled Entities

   The standard must provide means for an entity to report the list of
   all entities for which it can control the Power State.

8.1.4.  List of All Power State Controllers

   The standard must provide means for an entity that receives commands
   controlling its Power State from other entities to report the list of
   all those entities.

8.2.  Controlling Power Supply

   Some entities may have control of the power supply of other entities,
   for example, because the other entity is supplied via a Power Outlet
   of the entity.  For this and similar cases, means are needed to make
   this control accessible to the Energy Management System.  This need
   is already addressed by the requirement in Section 6.2.

   In addition, it is required that an entity that has its supply
   controlled by other entities has the means to report the list of
   these other entities.  This need is already addressed by requirements
   in Sections 5.2.3 and 5.2.4.

9.  Security Considerations

   Controlling Power State and power supply of entities are considered
   highly sensitive actions, since they can significantly affect the
   operation of directly and indirectly connected devices.  Therefore,
   all control actions addressed in Sections 6 and 8 must be
   sufficiently protected through authentication, authorization, and
   integrity protection mechanisms.





Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 23]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


   Entities that are not sufficiently secure to operate directly on the
   public Internet do exist and can be a significant cause of risk, for
   example, if the remote control functions described in Sections 6 and
   8 can be exercised on those devices from anywhere on the Internet.
   The standard needs to provide means for dealing with such cases.  One
   solution is providing means that allow the isolation of such devices,
   e.g., behind a sufficiently secured gateway.  Another solution is to
   allow compliant implementations to disable sensitive functions, or to
   not implement such functions at all.

   The monitoring of energy-related quantities of an entity as addressed
   in Sections 5 through 8 can be used to derive more information than
   just the received and provided energy; therefore, monitored data
   requires protection.  This protection includes authentication and
   authorization of entities requesting access to monitored data as well
   as confidentiality protection during transmission of monitored data.
   Privacy of stored data in an entity must be taken into account.
   Monitored data may be used as input to control, accounting, and other
   actions, so integrity of transmitted information and authentication
   of the origin may be needed.

9.1.  Secure Energy Management

   The standard must provide privacy, integrity, and authentication
   mechanisms for all actions addressed in Sections 5 through 8.  The
   security mechanisms must meet the security requirements detailed in
   Section 1.4 of [RFC3411].

9.2.  Isolation of Insufficiently Secure Entities

   The standard must provide means to allow the isolation of entities
   that are not sufficiently secure to operate on the public Internet,
   e.g., behind a gateway that implements sufficient security that the
   vulnerable entities are not directly exposed to the Internet.

9.3.  Optional Restriction of Functions

   The standard must allow compliant implementations to disable
   sensitive functions, or to not implement such functions at all, when
   operating in environments that are not sufficiently secured.  This
   applies particularly to the control functions described in Sections 6
   and 8.









Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 24]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


10.  Acknowledgments

   The authors would like to thank Ralf Wolter for his first essay on
   this document.  Many thanks to William Mielke, John Parello,
   JinHyeock Choi, Georgios Karagiannis, and Michael Suchoff for their
   helpful comments on the document.  Many thanks to Stephen Farrell,
   Robert Sparks, Adrian Farrel, Barry Leiba, Brian Haberman, Peter
   Resnick, Sean Turner, Stewart Bryant, and Ralph Droms for their IESG
   reviews.  Finally, special thanks to the document shepherd, Nevil
   Brownlee, and to the EMAN working group chairs: Nevil Brownlee and
   Bruce Nordman.

11.  References

11.1.  Normative References

   [ANSI-TIA-1057]
              Telecommunications Industry Association, ANSI-
              TIA-1057-2006, "TIA Standard -- Telecommunications -- IP
              Telephony Infrastructure -- Link Layer Discovery Protocol
              for Media Endpoint Devices", April 2006.

   [IEC.61850-7-4]
              International Electrotechnical Commission, "Communication
              networks and systems for power utility automation --
              Part 7-4: Basic communication structure -- Compatible
              logical node classes and data object classes", March 2010.

   [IEC.62053-21]
              International Electrotechnical Commission, "Electricity
              metering equipment (a.c.) -- Particular requirements --
              Part 21: Static meters for active energy (classes 1
              and 2)", January 2003.

   [IEC.62053-22]
              International Electrotechnical Commission, "Electricity
              metering equipment (a.c.) -- Particular requirements --
              Part 22: Static meters for active energy (classes 0,2 S
              and 0,5 S)", January 2003.

   [IEEE-100] IEEE, "The Authoritative Dictionary of IEEE Standards
              Terms, IEEE 100, Seventh Edition", December 2000.

   [IEEE-1621]
              Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers,
              "IEEE 1621-2004 - IEEE Standard for User Interface
              Elements in Power Control of Electronic Devices Employed
              in Office/Consumer Environments", 2004.



Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 25]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


   [IEEE-802.1AB]
              IEEE Computer Society, "IEEE Std 802.1AB-2009 -- IEEE
              Standard for Local and Metropolitan Area Networks --
              Station and Media Access Control Discovery",
              September 2009.

   [RFC3411]  Harrington, D., Presuhn, R., and B. Wijnen, "An
              Architecture for Describing Simple Network Management
              Protocol (SNMP) Management Frameworks", STD 62, RFC 3411,
              December 2002.

   [RFC3621]  Berger, A. and D. Romascanu, "Power Ethernet MIB",
              RFC 3621, December 2003.

   [RFC6933]  Bierman, A., Romascanu, D., Quittek, J., and M.
              Chandramouli, "Entity MIB (Version 4)", RFC 6933,
              May 2013.

11.2.  Informative References

   [EMAN-STATEMENT]
              Schoening, B., Chandramouli, M., and B. Nordman, "Energy
              Management (EMAN) Applicability Statement", Work in
              Progress, April 2013.

   [IEC.60050]
              International Electrotechnical Commission, "Electropedia:
              The World's Online Electrotechnical Vocabulary", 2013,
              <http://www.electropedia.org/iev/iev.nsf/
              welcome?openform>.

   [ITU-M.3400]
              International Telecommunication Union, "ITU-T
              Recommendation M.3400 -- Series M: TMN and Network
              Maintenance: International Transmission Systems, Telephone
              Circuits, Telegraphy, Facsimile and Leased Circuits --
              Telecommunications Management Network - TMN management
              functions", February 2000.

   [RFC7011]  Claise, B., Ed., Trammell, B., Ed., and P. Aitken,
              "Specification of the IP Flow Information Export (IPFIX)
              Protocol for the Exchange of Flow Information", STD 77,
              RFC 7011, September 2013.

   [RFC7012]  Claise, B., Ed., and B. Trammell, Ed., "Information Model
              for IP Flow Information Export (IPFIX)", RFC 7012,
              September 2013.




Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 26]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


   [RFC5905]  Mills, D., Martin, J., Burbank, J., and W. Kasch, "Network
              Time Protocol Version 4: Protocol and Algorithms
              Specification", RFC 5905, June 2010.

Authors' Addresses

   Juergen Quittek (editor)
   NEC Europe Ltd.
   NEC Laboratories Europe
   Network Research Division
   Kurfuersten-Anlage 36
   Heidelberg  69115
   Germany

   Phone: +49 6221 4342-115
   EMail: quittek@neclab.eu


   Mouli Chandramouli
   Cisco Systems, Inc.
   Sarjapur Outer Ring Road
   Bangalore
   India

   Phone: +91 80 4426 3947
   EMail: moulchan@cisco.com


   Rolf Winter
   NEC Europe Ltd.
   NEC Laboratories Europe
   Network Research Division
   Kurfuersten-Anlage 36
   Heidelberg  69115
   Germany

   Phone: +49 6221 4342-121
   EMail: Rolf.Winter@neclab.eu













Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 27]
^L
RFC 6988           Requirements for Energy Management     September 2013


   Thomas Dietz
   NEC Europe Ltd.
   NEC Laboratories Europe
   Network Research Division
   Kurfuersten-Anlage 36
   Heidelberg  69115
   Germany

   Phone: +49 6221 4342-128
   EMail: Thomas.Dietz@neclab.eu


   Benoit Claise
   Cisco Systems, Inc.
   De Kleetlaan 6a b1
   Diegem  1831
   Belgium

   Phone: +32 2 704 5622
   EMail: bclaise@cisco.com































Quittek, et al.               Informational                    [Page 28]
^L